Re: Re: Pirate PHP books online?

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



At 7:28 PM -0500 7/30/07, Larry Garfield wrote:
On Monday 30 July 2007, tedd wrote:
 > What about descendants of the author? When anyone dies, their
 descendants have a rightful claim on their parent's assets -- it been
 that way since the dawn of mankind. Do you think you know better than
 the practice of thousands of generations?

Actually no, property law didn't really come in until civilization, some 5000
years ago, which is rather small on the scale of "dawn of mankind".

Mankind has been on this Earth for more than a million years. Mankind's first known works of art were published in the caves of Altamira and Lascaux 15,000 to 10,000 B.C. Physical sculpted items such as the "Venus of Willendorf" were things that certainly could be passed down to descendants.

Are you telling me that the son of that artist did not claim ownership of that item after his father died? That doesn't seem reasonable. If you're father died, wouldn't you want to inherit his work? That seems more reasonable to me.


copyright didn't exist until perhaps 5 centuries ago in England, and covered
just publication, and was for less than 20 years.  Copyright being long
enough term for inheritance to matter is less than a century.  Over the scale
of human history, unrestricted information flow has been the rule, not the
exception.

Over the scale of history, it was usually the strongest who took what they wanted.


But what you're suggesting is that legalized extortion should be inheritable. Copyright is, fundamentally, legalized extortion as a means of "promoting the
progress of Science and the Useful Arts".

Extortion? Are you saying that anyone who owes a copyright is obtaining money through force or threats? That sounds strange.


Do you keep paying the guy who
built your TV every time you watch something on it?  Do you keep paying the
company that built your house every time you move?  Do you pay your teachers
from college every time you use something you learned there?  Do you pay your
dentist every time you eat?

No, I pay them for their service. The same way I pay for a book or software. Your points are getting stranger.


This from the man who just claimed that perpetual copyright for all decedents
of an artist was a fundamental part of human existence for as long as they've
been humans.  Can we stick to facts when making logical arguments rather than
completely made up nonsense?

I didn't say perpetual, but the rest is basically common sense.

In Geology there is an axiom that says "The present is the key to the past" -- while it's not perfect, it does seem to work surprisingly well.

I don't think that mankind 15,000 years ago was that much different than today and if today's descendants are fighting over their parent's processions now, then I don't think that it's unreasonable to project that conduct back 15,000 years and make a statement to that effect. So, it's not made up nonsense. Besides, that's the way I remember it.

Cheers,

tedd

--
-------
http://sperling.com  http://ancientstones.com  http://earthstones.com

--
PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/)
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php


[Index of Archives]     [PHP Home]     [Apache Users]     [PHP on Windows]     [Kernel Newbies]     [PHP Install]     [PHP Classes]     [Pear]     [Postgresql]     [Postgresql PHP]     [PHP on Windows]     [PHP Database Programming]     [PHP SOAP]

  Powered by Linux