Hi, I'm not sure what this could depend on, we successfully use both Eyebeam and X-lite without problems, so I would say PJSUA is definitely compatible with both. What is you configuration are both behind the same NAT or different NAT? What isn't working is it SIP signaling or RTP? You could mail me a pcap file if you want. BR/Olle _____ From: w zl [mailto:wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx] Sent: den 27 september 2008 01:34 To: Olle Frimanson Cc: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP Hi, I did test in same enviroment but by using two pjsip clients, they worked! Does it mean, pjsip is not compatible with X-Lite, I use X-Lite version 3.0 build 47546. Actually I tried some other sip clients before, I could not find one that works with pjsip. Can you recommend a sip client? Wwzhdo --- On Fri, 9/26/08, w zl <wwzhdo at yahoo.com> wrote: From: w zl <wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx> Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP To: "Olle Frimanson" <olle.frimanson at keystream.se> Cc: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org Date: Friday, September 26, 2008, 4:03 PM Hi Olle, Still doesn't work. I added cfg.stun_host = pj_str("stun.iptel.org");in simple pjsua sample application; and I also tried setting --stun-srv stun.iptel.org when start pjsua sample application. Neither works. I made call from pjsua to X-Lite, X-Lite received the call, however, the problem is still same, both clients send packets to sip server, I tested against iptel.org. Any suggestion? I could send you ethereal trace if it helps. thanks Leo --- On Thu, 9/25/08, Olle Frimanson <olle.frimanson at keystream.se> wrote: From: Olle Frimanson <olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx> Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com Date: Thursday, September 25, 2008, 12:50 PM Hi, PJSUA supports both STUN and ICE, so just compile from Trunk. Look at the instructions on www.pjsip.org Cheers / Olle _____ From: w zl [mailto:wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx] Sent: den 25 september 2008 21:30 To: Olle Frimanson Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP Thanks Olle, Can you let me know which API to set STUN sever in PJSIP? Does the PJSIP sample applications, PJSUA and simple PJSUA, support ICE by default? thanks Leo --- On Thu, 9/25/08, Olle Frimanson < olle.frimanson at keystream.se > wrote: From: Olle Frimanson < olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com Date: Thursday, September 25, 2008, 12:09 PM Hi I'm not sure on the SDP attribute you mentioned. But I would suggest you find a STUN server like stun.pjsip.org and turn on ICE on 2 PJSUA clients. And then try this usually solves any NAT issues, as a last resort you need a media relay or TURN server. If you try against X-lite I think Benny told me that they don't support the latest ICE version. Good luck / Olle _____ From: w zl [mailto:wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx] Sent: den 25 september 2008 20:40 To: Olle Frimanson; pjsip at lists.pjsip.org Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP Olle, thanks for your quick reply. I believe that PJSIP should work well, :-), I'm trying to figure out what wrong is on my side. I tested two X-Lite here inside company network, they worked fine. Acutually one SIP guy here mentioned that does PJSIP support "a=nortproxyyes" in SDP. Acoording to this guy, it will enable SIP client to commuicate with other SIP within local network. If PJSIP supports it, my PJSIP client might be configured in a wrong way. thanks wwzhdo --- On Thu, 9/25/08, Olle Frimanson < olle.frimanson at keystream.se > wrote: From: Olle Frimanson < olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com, "'pjsip list'" <pjsip at lists.pjsip.org> Date: Thursday, September 25, 2008, 10:40 AM Hi, we have over the last year tested PJSIP against several different SIP servers and PBX's (OpenSER, Avaya, Brekeke,...) and against several different phones (Snom, Polycom, Grandstream, Eyebeam, ..) So far it all works well, at least for us. Are you sure this is not a configuration issue, either on PJSIP or on server? If you are behind NAT a STUN server and enabling ICE will help a lot, but check that the other clients support ICE as well. BR/Olle _____ From: pjsip-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:pjsip-bounces at lists.pjsip.org] On Behalf Of w zl Sent: den 25 september 2008 19:06 To: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org Subject: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP Hello, It's my first post :-) It's a quite stupid question, what SIP server and SIP client do you guys use to test PJSIP client against? I'm asking this question because I tested PJSIP client against iptel sip server, X-Lite sip client and some other sip clients, but none of them really worked perfectly with PJSIP, especially when I tested inside company firewall. Any suggestions are welcome! thanks! wwzhdo -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: <http://lists.pjsip.org/pipermail/pjsip_lists.pjsip.org/attachments/20080928/3c381659/attachment-0001.html>
