Hi Olle, Both end-points were in the same NAT, by the way, I ran this test both in company and my home, neither worked. I attached one pcap in this email. Two end-points were in my home local network, pjsip client ran on mac, X-Lite ran on XP, I captured on XP/X-lite side. Please take a look, thank you in advance. (RTP didn't work, SIP signaling worked, I think) --- On Sun, 9/28/08, Olle Frimanson <olle.frimanson at keystream.se> wrote: > From: Olle Frimanson <olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx> > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use to test PJSIP > To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com > Cc: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org > Date: Sunday, September 28, 2008, 11:07 AM > Hi, I'm not sure what this could depend on, we > successfully use both Eyebeam > and X-lite without problems, so I would say PJSUA is > definitely compatible > with both. > > What is you configuration are both behind the same NAT or > different NAT? > What isn't working is it SIP signaling or RTP? > > You could mail me a pcap file if you want. > > BR/Olle > > > > _____ > > From: w zl [mailto:wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx] > Sent: den 27 september 2008 01:34 > To: Olle Frimanson > Cc: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > > > Hi, > I did test in same enviroment but by using two pjsip > clients, they worked! > Does it mean, pjsip is not compatible with X-Lite, I use > X-Lite version 3.0 > build 47546. > Actually I tried some other sip clients before, I could not > find one that > works with pjsip. > Can you recommend a sip client? > Wwzhdo > > > --- On Fri, 9/26/08, w zl <wwzhdo at yahoo.com> wrote: > From: w zl <wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx> > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > To: "Olle Frimanson" > <olle.frimanson at keystream.se> > Cc: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org > Date: Friday, September 26, 2008, 4:03 PM > > Hi Olle, > Still doesn't work. I added > cfg.stun_host = pj_str("stun.iptel.org");in > simple pjsua sample > application; and I also tried setting --stun-srv > stun.iptel.org when start > pjsua sample application. Neither works. > I made call from pjsua to X-Lite, X-Lite received the call, > however, the > problem is still same, both clients send packets to sip > server, I tested > against iptel.org. > > Any suggestion? I could send you ethereal trace if it > helps. > > thanks > Leo > > > --- On Thu, 9/25/08, Olle Frimanson > <olle.frimanson at keystream.se> wrote: > From: Olle Frimanson <olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx> > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com > Date: Thursday, September 25, 2008, 12:50 PM > Hi, PJSUA supports both STUN and ICE, so just compile from > Trunk. Look at > the instructions on www.pjsip.org > > Cheers / Olle > > _____ > > From: w zl [mailto:wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx] > Sent: den 25 september 2008 21:30 > To: Olle Frimanson > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > > > Thanks Olle, > Can you let me know which API to set STUN sever in PJSIP? > Does the PJSIP > sample applications, PJSUA and simple PJSUA, support ICE by > default? > > thanks > Leo > > > --- On Thu, 9/25/08, Olle Frimanson < > olle.frimanson at keystream.se > wrote: > From: Olle Frimanson < olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx > > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com > Date: Thursday, September 25, 2008, 12:09 PM > Hi I'm not sure on the SDP attribute you mentioned. But > I would suggest you > find a STUN server like stun.pjsip.org and turn on ICE on 2 > PJSUA clients. > > And then try this usually solves any NAT issues, as a last > resort you need a > media relay or TURN server. > > If you try against X-lite I think Benny told me that they > don't support the > latest ICE version. > > Good luck / Olle > > _____ > > From: w zl [mailto:wwzhdo@xxxxxxxxx] > Sent: den 25 september 2008 20:40 > To: Olle Frimanson; pjsip at lists.pjsip.org > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > > > > Olle, thanks for your quick reply. > I believe that PJSIP should work well, :-), I'm trying > to figure out what > wrong is on my side. > I tested two X-Lite here inside company network, they > worked fine. > > Acutually one SIP guy here mentioned that does PJSIP > support > "a=nortproxyyes" in SDP. Acoording to this guy, > it will enable SIP client to > commuicate with other SIP within local network. If PJSIP > supports it, my > PJSIP client might be configured in a wrong way. > > thanks > wwzhdo > --- On Thu, 9/25/08, Olle Frimanson < > olle.frimanson at keystream.se > wrote: > From: Olle Frimanson < olle.frimanson@xxxxxxxxxxxx > > Subject: RE: what SIP server and SIP client shall I > use to test > PJSIP > To: wwzhdo at yahoo.com, "'pjsip list'" > <pjsip at lists.pjsip.org> > Date: Thursday, September 25, 2008, 10:40 AM > Hi, we have over the last year tested PJSIP against several > different SIP > servers and PBX's (OpenSER, Avaya, Brekeke,...) and > against several > different phones (Snom, Polycom, Grandstream, Eyebeam, ..) > > So far it all works well, at least for us. Are you sure > this is not a > configuration issue, either on PJSIP or on server? > > If you are behind NAT a STUN server and enabling ICE will > help a lot, but > check that the other clients support ICE as well. > > BR/Olle > > _____ > > From: pjsip-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > [mailto:pjsip-bounces at lists.pjsip.org] > On Behalf Of w zl > Sent: den 25 september 2008 19:06 > To: pjsip at lists.pjsip.org > Subject: what SIP server and SIP client shall I use > to test PJSIP > > > Hello, > > It's my first post :-) > > It's a quite stupid question, what SIP server and SIP > client do you guys use > to test PJSIP client against? I'm asking this question > because I tested > PJSIP client against iptel sip server, X-Lite sip client > and some other sip > clients, but none of them really worked perfectly with > PJSIP, especially > when I tested inside company firewall. Any suggestions are > welcome! > > thanks! > wwzhdo
