-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA1 On 6/12/13 12:38 PM, Alexey Melnikov wrote: > On 12/06/2013 15:16, ned+ietf@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote: >> Dave Cridland wrote: >>> I strongly feel that positive statements have value, as they >>> allow the community to gauge the level of review and consensus, >>> and I suspect that human nature means that we get more reviews >>> if people get to brag about it. >> Agreed 100%. >> >> But also consider the likely effect of calling certain comments >> "useless". >> >> Discussions like this don't exactly fire me up with enthusiasm to >> expend additional time reviewing and commenting on documents not >> directly related to what I do. And I rather doubt I'm alone in >> this. > You are not alone. I do occasional reviews of documents not > directly related to what I do. But I hate paperworks. And if I > would be required to fill in 10 pages questionnaire about why I > think the document is in a good shape, I probably will stop doing > such reviews altogether. Much as I love Pete, IMHO this thread started because in good curmudgeonly style he needed something to grump at. In this instance, I suggest we just keep doing what we've always been doing. Peter - -- Peter Saint-Andre https://stpeter.im/ -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2.0.19 (Darwin) Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJRuMF+AAoJEOoGpJErxa2pAkwQAK6dse/oJRAS/kNcjvaKvOvD elHpEX54kil8v01wfiJ8/kd0fHSsKItR0m0r8b/YTkH/8I0+2dy+tG2F/gchI6uK OrJsev4vFcSY2yZM/qh3QAWeJ2HbYDRjHKc7yMDrwAwS8zUPiNRTfecsw6p/lWNw qj2H3R5bCIIkIR0dQO5NvWhaEj6Edy/40rwLe1pOOKo5EiMGhut0lQWUV6Dqy3u/ SJAy/dYRexXLuZDuYkI1hGUMBDCmspqnWVOe/bX6oQ3MuC1wTFyZXNntgOlsWOnu QK7PkY9mNpSpd8KZ8Rt0LgMNEvsPKmNgggmD1Hx1RjBv5B/6SXPwKlT1jS3bZ2or eCcdHPxLbTD06Ec1Ukg2vNiFe+kgVz5rXHe4GuBm7RQFvMTkq2jO5AF8MddKjtoi wfW5ociPNQCqIjGkj+xM9CJS6aSQaQxUk0DPzxjwoUAYSIxcF4VIsB0uY/JUs5n0 41deCNgp26OAyvcxdTFW3pgD2vWX+BTA+H6w+0VzLd0msvousDi+tm5wPiQml3+y Us6wSZwNrxdBgCp7Ce5BAyEaLFQ+LhtOqW3ElJv+AiNgKOujH5lhnNPfsd7jRWHF Ca4m3XxhFsri+Hw9sr7D2PtUWWJZ4ntm32zfZVKRDM6SXXvUzpZoGAzzgwTOf2Zj UTBku2xoH8Khfloa29y1 =79mX -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----