Wolfgang Rohdewald wrote: > On Dienstag 10 Januar 2006 17:28, Klaus Schmidinger wrote: > >>For everything else I believe the current behavior is the only >>consistent way. Anything else would again open non-consistency >>discussions. >> >>Sure, if you're used to the old way, the new way may need some >>getting used to (same here ;-). But I'm sure that's only temporary ;-) > > > this new behaviour makes the number of key presses to get into > the menu unpredictable. It can always happen that some message > is displayed just before you press Menu. If that happens you > have to press it a second time. > > So now you have to check on screen whether the key press really > did what you wanted it to do. > > The new behaviour is good for the muggle plugin - the Menu key > is the preferred way to leave it. > > > I think this would also be quite consistent: > > If the OSD covers less than half of the screen (so if either > the upper or the lower part of the screen is without OSD), > the Menu key shows the main menu. > > Otherwise it clears the OSD. I can already see people counting pixels and arguing whether this or that menu actually covered more than half of the screen ;-) Klaus
