2008. 02. 29, péntek keltezéssel 10.17-kor Colin Guthrie ezt írta: > Zoltán Németh wrote: > > I strongly recommend git. it has several great advantages above cvs or > > svn. for example, it does not store whole copies of the whole tree if > > you make a branch, but stores only the differences. it is much faster, > > and losing a commit is really hard even if you screw things up seriously > > (I know I've done that a couple of times when I was new to git, but I > > could manage to restore everything) > > Yeah git is definitely good, I don't deny that, but your comment about > storing whole copies when you make a branch does not hold true for SVN, > at least not with that statement... If you make a branch in SVN it is > free. If you make changes on the branch then commit it and subsequently > merge that branch back to the trunk/master/whatever *then* SVN will > store your changes twice, whereas git is cleverererer. yeah, sure, I wasn't exact. > > I think both have their advantages. For me, until Git integration into > Trac it's a non-starter as I use Trac heavily to track tickets/bugs, > time and view the repo etc. trac integration would be cool, maybe it will happen one day > > The other thing about git particularly for web projects that store > multiple revisions of binary data (images etc.) is that the git-clone > could end up taking up much more space than the SVN equiv. Due to the > fact that a git clone is essentially a full copy of the whole > repository, rather than just a "checkout" (SVN checkouts store twice as > much as the raw data but that's a constant). > > I love both systems but for me, I find that web projects with graphics > that have high churn are more suited to SVN but pure code projects > (which can include web projects) where branching is done often then git > wins hands down for features. yes, it might be true. for us, we have a very large codebase with minimal amount of binary data, and several branches, so we definitely go for git greets, Zoltán Németh > > My €0.02 :) > > Col > -- PHP General Mailing List (http://www.php.net/) To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
