Some quick thoughts ... can't do much as telephone line kaput at home. Dan Mitchell Cluttered Does nothing for me D.L. Shipman Posterisation of sun ? "Half and half" vertically - for me more of sky needed Richard Cooper Clever stitching Too-Small Picture Huge bytes for area. WRGill Underexposed Horizon perfectly level Run of the mill shot. Greg Fraser Barrel Distortion: pincushion is more flattering!!!! Too uncluttered/composed to be "life" - the photographer cannot hide that easily Rubin Diehl F. Great picture: something different. OK, she ain't that pretty - but the picture connects with the model .... My favourite this week. Per Ofverbeck "Scandinavia." Travel brochure filler shot. jIMMY Harris Good use of framing (the trees). Darryl Gage I don't like the black triangle above the legs. I do love most of the picture though. Original: 500 x 329 My crop: Remove 197 pixels from right Remove 41 pixels from top Remove 15 pixels from left Voila: square format and for me much more ambiguous - and no black triangle ;o) I would show my crop but ... that damned phone line stops me connecting. John Mason, Jr. Lies! Everyone knows Kodachrome does not last 40-y. The object on the path distracts - even if out of focus. Emily L. Ferguson EXIF - WGAF? The picture - does nowt for me. C J R Strevens "The author of this photograph is an Unknown Professional" Well, copyright is life + 70y (or in perpetuity if Disney get their way). There is a good chance this is still covered so should it be shown here? 1899? Imagine how much clearer it would have been from an inkjet.