On 1/3/14 8:33 AM, Eric Rosen wrote: > One has to look at the likely impact of the draft, not merely at the > intentions of the authors. I don't know if I'd use "likely" here but I definitely think the IETF should be somewhat more thoughtful about "possible." I've been trying to figure out if there's a way forward that doesn't involve bulldozing the dissenters. Personally, I'd be fine with publishing it as informational or experimental, or if the document provided a lot more clarity about the basis for review (along the lines of 3552). Melinda