I offer my signature to the recall petition. I am nomcom eligible. At this point, I believe the recall process is the correct process to follow unless there is an approved BCP update. In a case where there's been no contact and there's an argument we've found a gap in the procedures I can see the argument for creativity. However, according to Bob's note, Marshall has been contacted and rather than resigning, said he would consider resigning. I hope he does. Until he does, though, by considering resigning rather than resigning, he has implied that there might be a reason not to resign. In my mind that moves us out of a situation where creative interpretations of vacancy are appropriate. I think we're now in a position where there's a legitimate disagreement between Marshall and some members of the community about whether Marshall ought to be in his position. I believe the recall process is the only existing tool we have for resolving such a disagreement; I think permitting the IAOC to invent a process for resolving such a disagreement without an approved BCP is entirely inappropriate. Again, I hope this can all be side stepped by a resignation.