Lukasz
Sorry for the delay in replying. You are correct. There is a problem. The
solution is not the easy. Unfortunately there is no standard way of using
cryptoTokens to fix the problem. The issue is quite complex as you need to
put the support into GnuGk, the softphone and the MCU so a degree of design
thought is required.
In the short term the simplest way is to edit the openmcu code and remove
the default room support and force all callers to specify a room or of
course force the signalling to be routed. There is a major problem with
openMCU 2.2.1 not registering properly with the gatekeeper (uses some silly
alias and does not support passwords). I have checked in a fix for that. I
have also added MCU prefix support to GnuGk so openMCU can specify a E.164
prefix. This gets around the need to specify the MCU as a permanent endpoint.
I will put the solution on the to-do list.
Simon
At 05:09 PM 16/08/2007, =?ISO-8859-2?Q?=A3ukasz_Czekierda?= wrote:
>Hi Simon,
>
>Below I attach two traces. When routed mode is enabled, ARJ is sent, but
>it is when disabled, GK sends ACF. The MCU' name is 'MCU_2.2.1:pink' and
>the unregistered endpoints' name is 'xxx'.
> >From the endpoint (openh323-based) I called 'callto 149.156.97.26:7314'
>which is the transport address (H.225.0) of MCU.
>
>
>The routed mode section configuration is:
>
>[RoutedMode]
>GKRouted=1
>H245Routed=0
>RemoveH245AddressOnTunneling=0
>AcceptNeighborsCalls=1
>AcceptUnregisteredCalls=0
>SupportNATedEndpoints=1
>DropCallsByReleaseComplete=1
>
>Is it a correct bahaviour of GK (I mean with no routed mode it should or
>should not reject calls from unregistered endpoints)?
>
>With best regards,
>Lukasz
>
>
>
>******* When routed mode is enabled I get:
>
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.140 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
>admissionRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 17218
> callType = pointToPoint <<null>>
> endpointIdentifier = 9 characters {
> 0033 0031 0038 0035 005f 0065 006e 0064 3185_end
> 0070 p
> }
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 14 characters {
> 004d 0043 0055 005f 0032 002e 0032 002e MCU_2.2.
> 0031 003a 0070 0069 006e 006b 1:pink
> }
> }
> destCallSignalAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 95 9c 61 1a ..a.
> }
> port = 7314
> }
> srcInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 28 characters {
> 006c 0075 006b 0065 0034 0034 0020 0028 luke44 (
> 0078 0078 0078 0029 0020 005b 0031 0034 xxx) [14
> 0039 002e 0031 0035 0036 002e 0039 0037 9.156.97
> 002e 0032 0036 005d .26]
> }
> }
> srcCallSignalAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 95 9c 61 1a ..a.
> }
> port = 5051
> }
> bandWidth = 100000
> callReferenceValue = 22369
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 6f 31 64 da 6a f9 18 10 8a e7 00 0c 6e 0a ee 4c o1d.j.......n..L
> }
> activeMC = FALSE
> answerCall = TRUE
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 55 2b 64 da 6a f9 18 10 8a e7 00 0c 6e 0a ee 4c
>U+d.j.......n..L
> }
> }
> gatekeeperIdentifier = 12 characters {
> 004d 0020 0047 0061 0074 0065 006b 0065 M Gateke
> 0065 0070 0065 0072 eper
> }
> tokens = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> tokenOID = 1.2.840.113548.10.1.2.1
> timeStamp = 1187254069
> challenge = 16 octets {
> a3 06 ca 2a 2d 46 71 16 10 b1 1e 06 0c 6a 5d ce
>...*-Fq......j].
> }
> random = 40
> generalID = 15 characters {
> 004d 0043 0055 005f 0032 002e 0032 002e MCU_2.2.
> 0031 003a 0070 0069 006e 006b 0000 1:pink
> }
> }
> }
> willSupplyUUIEs = TRUE
> canMapSrcAlias = FALSE
> }
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.234 5 job.cxx(180) JOB Starting
>Job ARQ at Worker thread 3720
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.234 5 job.cxx(354) JOB Worker
>threads: 10 total - 10 busy, 0 idle
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.234 1 RasSrv.cxx(368) RAS ARQ
>Received
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.234 4 gkauth.cxx(2153) GKAUTH PrefixAuth
>rule matched and could not reject or accept destination prefix 'ALL' for
>alias
>'MCU_2.2.1:pink'
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.234 4 gkauth.cxx(2169) GKAUTH PrefixAuth
>could not reject or accept the request
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.234 5 gkauth.cxx(1191) GKAUTH
>SimplePasswordAuth cached password found for 'MCU_2.2.1:pink'
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.250 5 gkauth.cxx(1241) GKAUTH
>SimplePasswordAuth CAT password match for 'MCU_2.2.1:pink'
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.250 3 gkauth.cxx(964) GKAUTH
>SimplePasswordAuth ARQ check ok
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.250 2 RasSrv.cxx(413)
>ARJ|149.156.97.26:7314|MCU_2.2.1:pink:h323_ID|luke44 (xxx)
>[149.156.97.26]:h323_ID|true|routeCallTo
>Gatekeeper;
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.265 3 RasSrv.cxx(250) RAS Send to
>149.156.97.26:5047
>admissionReject {
> requestSeqNum = 17218
> rejectReason = routeCallToGatekeeper <<null>>
> }
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.281 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent
>Successful
>2007/08/16 10:47:49.281 5 job.cxx(417) JOB Job ARQ
>deleted
>
>
>**** When routed mode is disabled I get:
>
>
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.609 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
>admissionRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 17204
> callType = pointToPoint <<null>>
> endpointIdentifier = 9 characters {
> 0033 0031 0038 0035 005f 0065 006e 0064 3185_end
> 0070 p
> }
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 14 characters {
> 004d 0043 0055 005f 0032 002e 0032 002e MCU_2.2.
> 0031 003a 0070 0069 006e 006b 1:pink
> }
> }
> destCallSignalAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 95 9c 61 1a ..a.
> }
> port = 7314
> }
> srcInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 28 characters {
> 006c 0075 006b 0065 0034 0034 0020 0028 luke44 (
> 0078 0078 0078 0029 0020 005b 0031 0034 xxx) [14
> 0039 002e 0031 0035 0036 002e 0039 0037 9.156.97
> 002e 0032 0036 005d .26]
> }
> }
> srcCallSignalAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 95 9c 61 1a ..a.
> }
> port = 5049
> }
> bandWidth = 100000
> callReferenceValue = 31026
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 40 27 c0 d5 6a f9 18 10 96 6b 00 0c 6e 0a ee 4c @'..j....k..n..L
> }
> activeMC = FALSE
> answerCall = TRUE
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 26 21 c0 d5 6a f9 18 10 96 6b 00 0c 6e 0a ee 4c
>&!..j....k..n..L
> }
> }
> gatekeeperIdentifier = 12 characters {
> 004d 0020 0047 0061 0074 0065 006b 0065 M Gateke
> 0065 0070 0065 0072 eper
> }
> tokens = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> tokenOID = 1.2.840.113548.10.1.2.1
> timeStamp = 1187253290
> challenge = 16 octets {
> 27 fd 87 1b bb 11 46 c4 e2 39 7e 0b 54 59 50 b5
>'.....F..9~.TYP.
> }
> random = 36
> generalID = 15 characters {
> 004d 0043 0055 005f 0032 002e 0032 002e MCU_2.2.
> 0031 003a 0070 0069 006e 006b 0000 1:pink
> }
> }
> }
> willSupplyUUIEs = TRUE
> canMapSrcAlias = FALSE
> }
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.734 5 job.cxx(354) JOB Worker
>threads: 4 total - 4 busy, 0 idle
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.734 5 job.cxx(180) JOB Starting
>Job ARQ at Worker thread 2892
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.734 1 RasSrv.cxx(368) RAS ARQ
>Received
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.734 4 gkauth.cxx(2153) GKAUTH PrefixAuth
>rule matched and could not reject or accept destination prefix 'ALL' for
>alia
>'MCU_2.2.1:pink'
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.734 4 gkauth.cxx(2169) GKAUTH PrefixAuth
>could not reject or accept the request
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 5 gkauth.cxx(1191) GKAUTH
>SimplePasswordAuth cached password found for 'MCU_2.2.1:pink'
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 5 gkauth.cxx(1241) GKAUTH
>SimplePasswordAuth CAT password match for 'MCU_2.2.1:pink'
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 3 gkauth.cxx(964) GKAUTH
>SimplePasswordAuth ARQ check ok
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 3 RasSrv.cxx(2137) GK ARQ will
>request bandwith of 100000
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 2 RasTbl.cxx(2291)
>CallTable::Insert(CALL) Call No. 1, total sessions : 1
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 2 RasSrv.cxx(413)
>ACF|149.156.97.26:7314|3185_endp|31026|MCU_2.2.1:pink:h323_ID|luke44 (xxx)
>[149.156.97.26]:h323_I
>true;
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.750 3 RasSrv.cxx(250) RAS Send to
>149.156.97.26:5047
>admissionConfirm {
> requestSeqNum = 17204
> bandWidth = 100000
> callModel = direct <<null>>
> destCallSignalAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 00 00 00 00 ....
> }
> port = 0
> }
> irrFrequency = 88
> willRespondToIRR = FALSE
> uuiesRequested = {
> setup = FALSE
> callProceeding = FALSE
> connect = FALSE
> alerting = FALSE
> information = FALSE
> releaseComplete = FALSE
> facility = FALSE
> progress = FALSE
> empty = FALSE
> status = FALSE
> statusInquiry = FALSE
> setupAcknowledge = FALSE
> notify = FALSE
> }
> serviceControl = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> sessionId = 0
> contents = callCreditServiceControl {
> callStartingPoint = connect <<null>>
> }
> reason = refresh <<null>>
> }
> }
> }
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.859 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent
>Successful
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.875 5 job.cxx(417) JOB Job ARQ
>deleted
>2007/08/16 10:34:50.875 5 job.cxx(406) JOB Worker
>threads: 4 total - 3 busy, 1 idle
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.109 5 yasocket.cxx(771) RasSrv 1 sockets
>selected from 3, total 3/0
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.125 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving
>on 149.156.97.26:1719(U)
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.125 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from
>149.156.97.26:5047
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.156 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
>infoRequestResponse {
> requestSeqNum = 17205
> endpointType = {
> vendor = {
> vendor = {
> t35CountryCode = 9
> t35Extension = 0
> manufacturerCode = 61
> }
> productId = 24 octets {
> 50 6f 73 74 20 49 6e 63 72 65 6d 65 6e 74 20 4f Post
>Increment O
> 70 65 6e 4d 43 55 00 00 penMCU..
> }
> versionId = 26 octets {
> 32 2e 32 2e 31 20 28 4f 70 65 6e 48 33 32 33 20 2.2.1
>(OpenH323
> 76 31 2e 31 39 2e 30 29 00 00 v1.19.0)..
> }
> }
> mcu = {
> }
> mc = TRUE
> undefinedNode = FALSE
> }
> endpointIdentifier = 9 characters {
> 0033 0031 0038 0035 005f 0065 006e 0064 3185_end
> 0070 p
> }
> rasAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 95 9c 61 1a ..a.
> }
> port = 5047
> }
> callSignalAddress = 2 entries {
> [0]=ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 95 9c 61 1a ..a.
> }
> port = 7314
> }
> [1]=ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 00 00 00 00 ....
> }
> port = 7314
> }
> }
> endpointAlias = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 14 characters {
> 004d 0043 0055 005f 0032 002e 0032 002e MCU_2.2.
> 0031 003a 0070 0069 006e 006b 1:pink
> }
> }
> perCallInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> callReferenceValue = 31026
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 40 27 c0 d5 6a f9 18 10 96 6b 00 0c 6e 0a ee 4c
>@'..j....k..n..L
> }
> originator = FALSE
> audio = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> rtpAddress = {
> }
> rtcpAddress = {
> }
> cname = "SYSTEMpink"
> ssrc = 2219868020
> sessionId = 1
> associatedSessionIds = 0 entries {
> }
> }
> }
> h245 = {
> }
> callSignaling = {
> }
> callType = pointToPoint <<null>>
> bandWidth = 792
> callModel = direct <<null>>
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 26 21 c0 d5 6a f9 18 10 96 6b 00 0c 6e 0a ee 4c
>&!..j....k..n..L
> }
> }
> substituteConfIDs = 0 entries {
> }
> usageInformation = {
> nonStandardUsageFields = 0 entries {
> }
> connectTime = 1187253291
> }
> }
> }
> needResponse = FALSE
> unsolicited = TRUE
> }
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.406 5 job.cxx(180) JOB Starting
>Job IRR at Worker thread 2892
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.406 5 job.cxx(354) JOB Worker
>threads: 4 total - 4 busy, 0 idle
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.406 1 RasSrv.cxx(368) RAS IRR
>Received
>2007/08/16 10:34:51.406 5 job.cxx(417) JOB Job IRR
>deleted
>
>
>
> >Sorry for the delay in replying however I just tried using openMCU
> >registered with GnuGk and using an unregistered PacPhone (openH323 based)
> >calling the MCU. I get an ARJ from GnuGk with reason routetogatekeeper.
>
> >Can you post a level 5 Trace from GnuGk showing the problem?
>
>
>
>-------------------------------------------------------------------------
>This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc.
>Still grepping through log files to find problems? Stop.
>Now Search log events and configuration files using AJAX and a browser.
>Download your FREE copy of Splunk now >> http://get.splunk.com/
>_______________________________________________________
>
>Posting: mailto:Openh323gk-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>Archive:
>http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?forum_name=openh323gk-users
>Unsubscribe: http://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openh323gk-users
>Homepage: http://www.gnugk.org/
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Splunk Inc.
Still grepping through log files to find problems? Stop.
Now Search log events and configuration files using AJAX and a browser.
Download your FREE copy of Splunk now >> http://get.splunk.com/
_______________________________________________________
Posting: mailto:Openh323gk-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Archive: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?forum_name=openh323gk-users
Unsubscribe: http://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openh323gk-users
Homepage: http://www.gnugk.org/
