On Tue, 2 Feb 2010, Nicolas Mailhot wrote: > > Le Mar 2 février 2010 11:35, Kevin Kofler a écrit : >> >> Nicolas Mailhot wrote: >>> That is your interpretation. I see nothing on this page to support this >>> claim. And actually it is contrary to format #3 logic, since its main >>> difference with other changelog formats is that the version is not part of >>> the entry header, so there's no reason to limit one entry to one version >> >> It's blatantly obvious that all these formats have one thing in common: >> there's one entry per new EVR. > > Again, this is your interpretation > >> Our automated tools (e.g. make clog as >> already pointed out by Michael Schwendt) also expect that. > > IIRC when this guideline was written rpm devs complained the EVR was never > supposed to be in the changelog header, it was supposed to end at the email > mode and the EVR was an emacs rpm mode addition. Nervertheless FPC chose to > accept existing practices. This still applies: in the changelog styles #1 and #2, the EVR ends up being a part of the email address which is hardly "right". rpm -q --qf "[%{changelogname}\n]" <pkg> > This changelog style conforms to the existing spec, it has been in use in > Fedora for several years, it may surprise you, but changing the spec > retroactively is not the way to prove your point. The problem in the example you provided in http://lists.fedoraproject.org/pipermail/devel/2010-February/130062.html is that it lumps two EVR's into a single changelog entry. That just doesn't make sense. Taking the same changelog snippet (style #1): * Thu Jan 28 2010 Michael Schwendt <mschwendt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> - 2.2-10 - Fix tuple_copy() further (it was completely broken as the mowgli dict wasn't copied at all). * Thu Jan 28 2010 Michael Schwendt <mschwendt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> - 2.2-9 - Let set_tuple_cb() work on a copied tuple (the metadata updates flood is too racy IMO). - Fix tuple_copy(). In style #3 it would be: * Thu Jan 28 2010 Michael Schwendt <mschwendt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> - 2.2-10 - Fix tuple_copy() further (it was completely broken as the mowgli dict wasn't copied at all). * Thu Jan 28 2010 Michael Schwendt <mschwendt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> - 2.2-9 - Let set_tuple_cb() work on a copied tuple (the metadata updates flood is too racy IMO). - Fix tuple_copy(). - Panu - -- devel mailing list devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/devel