On Tue, 13 Sep 2016 21:48:10 +0200 Adrian Reber <adrian@xxxxxxxx> wrote: > On Tue, Sep 13, 2016 at 12:05:27PM -0600, Kevin Fenzi wrote: > > Greetings. > > > > We currently have 3 lists associated with mirrors. 2 of them are > > still located at redhat.com and we want to move them over to our > > infrastructure. > > > > mirror-admins@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx > > It actually is mirror-admin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (without the 's' > after admin). Which is probably irrelevant for this discussion. Oh yeah, sorry. :) > > This list is open to all (but only allows posting to subscribers, I > > moderate it and adrianr also does). This is usually the list we have > > people with questions or issues post to to get help mirroring. > > > > mirror-list-announce@xxxxxxxxxx > > Without announce, just mirror-list@xxxxxxxxxx > > > This list was for announcing new releases and sizes for mirrors so > > they would know to sync up and how large our next release was and > > to expect more traffic. It was setup back in the Fedora Core days > > so it was restricted to only approved mirror admins (because it > > would get notice of releases before they were public). > > > > mirror-list-d@xxxxxxxxxx > > > > This was another Fedora Core days list thats restricted to list > > admins to discuss space issues or mirroring problems or whatever. > > > > So, I propose we do this: > > > > * Make a new mirror-announce list. > > * Mass invite mirror-list-announce@xxxxxxxxxx people to it. > > * Make it open to all, but moderated > > * Mass invite mirror-list-d@xxxxxxxxxxx subscribers to mirror-admins > > list. > > * Mail redhat.com lists and close them to new posts. > > So both lists will be open to all and moderated? Or will one list be > only open for members posts? Or does 'Make it open to all, but > moderated' mean anybody can subscribe but every post (also of members) > will be moderated? I meant that the announce list will have all subscribers moderated but be open to subscription from anyone and the discussion list will have all non subscribers moderated and be open to subscription from anyone. ie, I see 0 reason to try and confirm someone is a "official" mirror admin before allowing them to subscribe to the lists. The announces can be public as well since there's really no surprises since we announce them a week ahead at least. > > Then, moving forward we send announcements about upcoming releases > > to mirror-announce and important changes (like archiving a release > > or a new mirroring tool or whatever). > > > > Thoughts? Other ideas? > > Sounds good. It is not clear yet which list has which mail acceptance > policy but as it can be changed anytime this might also be something > which can be adapted to our needs. Sure. kevin
Attachment:
pgp5trh64_5B_.pgp
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ infrastructure mailing list infrastructure@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://lists.fedoraproject.org/admin/lists/infrastructure@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
