2010/12/4 Máirín Duffy <duffy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
On Sat, 2010-12-04 at 21:51 -0500, Greg DeKoenigsberg wrote:I've probably spent a lot more time discussing front page real estate on
> Now I wonder if you can take the next step, and consider "front page
> real estate" one of those issues that might be worth discussing.
> Because as of right now, it seems as though you're rejecting that
> discussion out of hand.
the website than most people in Fedora. Check this out:
http://duffy.fedorapeople.org/temp/woot/
Those 17 mockups of the main download page are just a fraction of the
mockups and hours of discussion on IRC and mailing lists.
With limited design resources is this the best way to be expending
design time & effort? I'd personally rather work on things where I don't
get accused of hubris and secret hidden evil intentions.
First of all, I'm not accusing you of secret hidden evil intentions. As far as hubris, shrug. I've been guilty of it often enough. It was not meant as a personal affront; it was a reaction to the tone of a particular response.
As far as how we spend our time, I believe that this particular issue represents a serious rift in very productive parts of our community, which is why I believe it's worth the time to continue to discuss it.
The Spins site is beautiful and useful. Are we doing enough to promote it? Could we do more? Could we have an ad on the front page that rotates through and gives the other spins some real estate?
The Spins folks believe that their work languishes in a corner. Is there a way to please everybody with limited real estate? Probably not. Is there more that we can do to give individual spins more exposure? Probably so. Do the Spins people keep asking for that very thing? Seems to me that they do.
> I believe that there are creative ways of making it clear that thereThat's why we have a www.fedoraproject.org geared towards the novice,
> is One Approved Choice for the novice, while at the same time doing
> more to celebrate some of our other spins. I really, truly, deeply
> believe that.
and spins.fedoraproject.org as more of an
r&d-look-at-the-other-cool-things-fedora-can-do sort of space.
We actually designed, developed, and launched spins.fedoraproject.org a
full two releases before the new www.fedoraproject.org specifically to
avoid the spins feeling outed. A lot of time, effort, and love went into
both of those designs, but I can't force the spins owners to take
advantage of what we built with & for them there.
Spins.fp.o is awesome. How many people go there? Is it unfair of Spins folks to ask for help in promoting that excellent page you've developed?
> Can we have that conversation without characterizing it as "aWhen people stop telling me that large classes of users 'have no
> choose-your-own adventure clubhouse type of affair"?
business' using Linux I will stop referring to them specifically as
clubhousers.
Subtracting that word, there's still the inference that giving more real estate to other spins from time to time is necessarily
Hubristically yours
-1 sarcasm. ;)
--g
_______________________________________________ advisory-board mailing list advisory-board@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/advisory-board
