_______________________ Pini Vollach http://www.pinimage.com Bob wrote: It's all too easy to fall back on purely structural comments (cropping, exposure, rotation, thirds) which most here appear to resent. In a way I guess they are comments on a picture that wasn't shown, rather than dealing with emotions to the one that was. I agree ! I think Emily did it nicely with Veli picture this week, she didn't tell him how to crop but she did tell him about her feelings to the spaces in his image. Pini Bon