Jeff Just because something has been done does not mean we should not try to do better ... does it? If you really want I codified form, I found the link to the one I posted almost a year ago. http://www.middletownk12.org/north/photopg/critique_guide.htm Maybe someone else could follow this for all 12 images in next week's gallery ... I sure as hell don't have the time ;o0 Bob > CRAP, sCRAP, why invent something new? I suggest that reviewers fill this > out for each of the photos: >