To clarify matters, in any future reviews I will be assessing images in the PF gallery by four criteria, C, R, A and P. C - Content: what is the photo of? what is it's purpose R - Reaction: what does the image say? what impact does it have? A - Aesthetics: the artistic / compositional elements. What of the photographer is in the image P - Practice: the more technical aspects of photographic technique. Is it sharp? Is it well lit/exposed Basically, if the weighted CRAP score is high, then, IMO, the photo is anything but crap and vice versa. Sadly, there is no room ion my book for the "Artist's statement" - sorry Mr unRosen ;o( Bob