Thank you Alan, When I took this photo I was looking for a way to shoot it clean without any strange objects in the frame. It couldn't be done there but I could crop it in PS7 but then I decided that it is better this way. I happened to me at the past that such objects that while shooting I was thinking how to put out of frame were at last the point of the picture. This time the object is not the point but doesn't distract also IMO. I would like to hear more opinions about this. I was thinking like you Alan about cropping this image. Pini _______________________ Pini Vollach http://www.pinimage.com -----Original Message----- From: owner-photoforum@listserver.isc.rit.edu [mailto:owner-photoforum@listserver.isc.rit.edu]On Behalf Of Alan P. Hayes Sent: Friday, May 02, 2003 3:21 AM To: List for Photo/Imaging Educators - Professionals - Students Subject: RE: Gallery comments - 28/04/2003 I think maybe its the extent of the rail, and the dark gray floor that it really hurts to lose. I wouldn't crop it. Personally, the dark thing didn't bother me, but I tend not to object to imperfect realities in photos that seem to bother a lot of people. At 0:47 +0200 5/1/03, Pinimage wrote: >Thomas wrote:" I would have cut away the dark thing >in lower left corner " >Do everyone think he is right ? >Isn't this thing take you back to reality and make your eye travel along the >frame ? > >Pini > > >_______________________ >Pini Vollach >http://www.pinimage.com > > >Pini Vollach - : >Nice abstraction, pure, clean form. I would have cut away the dark thing >in lower left corner by cropping maybe 5% from below. Or maybe you could >have shot from slightly lower to eliminate it and make the low white >wall touch the corner of the picture. -- Alan P. Hayes Meaning and Form: Writing, Editing and Document Design Pittsfield, Massachusetts New photographs at <http://photo.elay.org/albums.php>
