So if it isnt the firewall, then what on earth could it be? Because from the tethereal output, you can see that FTP-DATA isnt being sent, any idea of what could cause this? If i remove the nat, and ftp things direct the firewall it works fine, it's only if I nat stuff to a ftp behind the firewall. ---------------------------------- On 11/9/05, /dev/rob0 <rob0@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > On Wednesday 2005-November-09 09:40, Dave Strydom wrote: > > Ok, so this is what it has all been reduced to, and I'm still > > getting the same problem: > > What more can I say? > > > Calypso ~ # iptables-save > > This is like not having a firewall at all. The only functional part is > the NAT, DNAT FTP inbound, MASQUERADE LAN clients outbound. > > Not having a firewall is not necessarily a disaster, BTW. A properly > configured system should still be safe without it. > -- > mail to this address is discarded unless "/dev/rob0" > or "not-spam" is in Subject: header > >