Quoting Ralf Mardorf <ralf.mardorf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>:
In taberna quando sumus, we could first drink on the libre to be free to like or not to like lossy codecs. If the codec is ok for the tests, you don't have a guaranty that it will be ok for another recording at another time, so for me there's no reason to risk loss, resp. always to test listen if the MP3 is ok or not ok for a specific recording. Use MP3! I don't use it!
No one is forcing you to use it and if you don't want to you definitely shouldn't. But if you can't hear the difference between an original file and a properly encoded MP3 file why are you claiming the latter sounds crap?
Yes, lots of the Napster MP3 era were produced using sub-par encoders and even at high bitrate you could definitely hear the cymbals being mutilated, for instance, but the lame codec today is more or less 100% transparent for more or less 100% of the population at sufficiently (128-192 kbps) high bitrate for causal and semi-casual listening.
Unless you can prove in an ABX test that you can hear the positions of the sound being altered or whatever you might want to listen for your loath for the format is purely based on belief and not facts.
MP3 isn't just a thorn in my side regarding to it's quality, but also to the way music is misused today. MP3 for me stands for music 24/7. I don't eat chocolate the whole day, I don't have sex the whole day and I even won't hear good music the whole day.
Again the quality claim though you still haven't shown any indication of really being able to tell the difference.
You might not be aware of this but it is quite possible to just listen to one single 3 minute MP3 song and then turn off the stereo/computer/iPod. No one is forcing you to listen to the entire MP3 version of Wagner's Ring in one take.
And if you only sold music to connoisseurs who knew how to enjoy their 192/24, impeccable, transparent recordings and who only listened to the sound between the notes and the position of the instruments "in the room" you wouldn't be able to feed many mouths...
It feels like I'm banging my head against a brickwall limited ceiling here so I think I'll drop these conversations until we eventually see some numbers from you.
- Peder _______________________________________________ Linux-audio-user mailing list Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
