-> I think it depends on the type of traffic you're -> expecting from the different users. If you're -> expecting very similar patterns of behaviour, then my -> guess would be ESFQ would be the better. -> -> If, on the other hand, the network load is going to -> shift over time, between the users, then WRR would -> seem the more logical choice. -> -> You might also want to look at HFSC (Heirarchical Fair -> Service Curve) - it's possible you might be able to -> get what you want from the single algorithm, rather -> than piping through several. The fewer layers you -> have, the less latency you'll introduce. HFSC also has -> the advantage that it is standard in the kernel, so -> likely has better testing. OK. I've read some domcumments about HFSC, but at the momment I understand it. Can you post me a good tutorial about HFSC ? thank you. -> -> ESFQ and WRR have been forward-ported, well, -> sometimes, but only the combined -qos patch seems to -> be current - the individual patches don't seem to be -> maintained at all. -> -> I would like to see the patches cleaned up (as -> necessary) then submitted for merging into the -> mainstream kernel. Linux' QoS code is in frankly -> horrible shape at the moment, so anything that stirred -> interest in it would almost have to be a good thing, -> even if the patches themselves didn't get included any -> time soon. -> -> --- LinuXKiD <gregoriandres@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: -> -> > Hi -> > -> > If I have a HTB class with 128kbit, and I want to -> > put "N" users in that class ( in order to share -> > bandwidth fairly ) , -> > -> > which is better for me ? esfq (hash dst) or wrr ? -> > -> > I would attach esfq or wrr to HTB parent class. -> > -> > Also I've readed on Jim script that over WRR put -> > a RED qdisc, but I don't understand it. -> > -> > bests -> > -> > andres -> > _______________________________________________ -> > LARTC mailing list -> > LARTC@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx -> > -> http://mailman.ds9a.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/lartc -> > -> -> -> -> -> __________________________________ -> Start your day with Yahoo! - Make it your home page! -> http://www.yahoo.com/r/hs _______________________________________________ LARTC mailing list LARTC@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx http://mailman.ds9a.nl/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/lartc
