Re: Can JMAP be proxied in a murder setup?

Ken Murchison <murch@xxxxxxxxxxxx> · Fri, 23 Jul 2021 07:06:13 -0400

I believe that JMAP should honor autocreate and the fact
      that it doesn't seems to be an oversight.

On 7/22/21 3:55 PM, David Luong wrote:
Hi Ken.

This is excellent news!

Another JMAP related issue I'd like your comment on.  I have
        enabled autocreate_inbox_folders in Cyrus IMAP but when
        the user is logged in via JMAP interface, the user's mailbox is
        not created. Instead, 500 Internal Server Error is returned. 
        See log below.  If I use IMAP protocol to login, the mailbox is
        auto created. Should JMAP behave the same way?

JMAP:
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        http_auth: found matching scheme: Basic
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]: login:
        [172.25.57.162] 15554441001 Basic User logged in
        SESSIONID=<cyrus-1626980623-858045-1-6232473965603291866>
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        sqldb_exec(/var/lib/imap/user/q/15554441001.dav): PRAGMA
        foreign_keys = ON;
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        sqldb_exec(/var/lib/imap/user/q/15554441001.dav): PRAGMA
        secure_delete = OFF;
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        sqldb_exec(/var/lib/imap/user/q/15554441001.dav): PRAGMA
        temp_store = 2;
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        sqldb_exec(/var/lib/imap/user/q/15554441001.dav): PRAGMA
        user_version;
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]: could
        not autoprovision calendars for userid 15554441001: Invalid user
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        auth_success returned error: 500 Internal Server Error
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]: auth
        failed - reinit
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        write_body(code = -1964266955, flags.te = 0, len = 489)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        simple_hdr(Date: Thu, 22 Jul 2021 19:03:43 GMT)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        simple_hdr(Connection: Upgrade)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        simple_hdr(Upgrade: h2c)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        simple_hdr(Vary: Accept-Encoding)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        simple_hdr(Content-Type: text/html; charset=utf-8)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        simple_hdr(Content-Length: 489)
Jul 22 19:03:43 rms01i.example.com cyrus/http[858045]:
        [172.25.57.162] as "15554441001" with "curl/7.54.0" via
        SESSIONID=<cyrus-1626980623-858045-1-6232473965603291866>;
        "POST /jmap/ HTTP/1.1" => "HTTP/1.1 500 Internal Server
        Error" (error=The server encountered an internal error.)
        [timing: cmd=0.017799 net=0.000000 total=0.017799]

IMAP:
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]:
        accepted connection
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]:
        extractor_init(0x55749ef10b90)
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin Parse the username 15554441001
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin try and connect to a host
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin trying to open db 'imap_db
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        begin transaction
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin create statement from userPassword
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin doing query SELECT password FROM imap_users WHERE
        username = '15554441001@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx';
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin: no result found
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        commit transaction
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin Parse the username 15554441001
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin try and connect to a host
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: SASL
        sql plugin trying to open db 'imap_db
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: login:
        pool-10-12-92-29.iot1.com [10.12.92.29] 15554441001 PLAIN User
        logged in
        SESSIONID=<cyrus-1626980690-858059-1-16985860205569064466>
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]:
        autocreateinbox: autocreate inbox for user 15554441001 was
        called
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]:
        autocreateinbox: User 15554441001, INBOX was successfully
        created
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]:
        autocreateinbox: User 15554441001, subfolder default creation
        succeeded.
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: User
        15554441001, Inbox subfolders, created 1, subscribed 0
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]: USAGE
        15554441001 user: 0.019144 sys: 0.010459
Jul 22 19:04:50 rms01i.example.com cyrus/imap[858059]:
        extractor_destroy(0x55749ef16930)
-- 
Kenneth Murchison
Senior Software Developer
Fastmail US LLC

Cyrus
  / Info / see
discussions
  +
participants
  +
delivery options
Permalink