On 3/21/19 3:21 AM, S Moonesamy wrote: > Hi Scott, > At 04:53 PM 20-03-2019, Scott O. Bradner wrote: >> are you referring to the people who could qualify for the noncom and >> those who could not? >> >> just trying to be sure what you are referring to > > I was referring to the rule in Section 7 of RFC 7437 which sets the > requirements for qualified signatories. I was not referring to the > nomcom process. > > Regards, > S. Moonesamy when we revisited this 10 years ago, the consensus was that if a recall petition didn't find enough signatures among the people who were nomcom-eligible, it was likely not a reasonable recall to pursue anyway. Unlike with nomcoms, a recall petition only needs a few signatures - most people who are active in the IETF know someone who's nomcom-eligible and could try to convince them to sign. The bar for initiating a recall is pretty low, given the size of the nomcom-eligible population. -- Surveillance is pervasive. Go Dark.
