Hi Brian, On Tue, Dec 15, 2015 at 10:35 AM, Brian Haberman <brian@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Hi Alexey, > > On 12/14/15 3:51 PM, Alexey Eromenko wrote: >>> >>> At this point I would suggest that the discussion on this topic has exceeded >>> the mandate for the list. I would suggest that creating a separate list and >>> announcing it and moving all further discussion on the specifics of this >>> proposal to that list would be appropriate. >>> >>> At the beginning of this discussion the question was asked of why the >>> sergeant at arms threatened posting restriction. I wasn't actually >>> surprised at that PR warning as we've already got a replacement for IPv4 in >>> the form of IPv6. It took us over 20 years to get from initial discussions >>> to reasonable deployments and we're still working on it. The form of the >>> proposal - BCD representation of IP addresses as its best claim to fame - >>> initially led me to believe it was a troll proposal rather than something >>> serious. I now see the author believes it to be a serious proposal, but I >>> also believe that it's 20 years too late and provides no benefit over IPv6. >>> I'm willing to be shown wrong, but I'd really like not to read further >>> discussions about it on this list until there's something of a buy in from a >>> greater crowd. >>> >>> Mike >> >> Fair enough. >> >> 1. How to create a mailing-list, (or Working Group) ? >> 2. Should I do it inside / as-part-of IETF, or some 3rd party resource ? >> > > I don't think there is a need for a new mailing list for this topic. > Rather, I suggest employing an existing list that we have for larger > architecture issues. Info on the list is available at: > > https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/architecture-discuss > > I would encourage folks interested in this topic to participate in the > discussion on the architecture-discuss list. > Right now, Alexey's protocols are being discussed in 5gangip list from 5G and next generation IP protocols perspective and I think he is getting quite good feedback :-) Regards, Behcet > Regards, > Brian >