> I read this draft and tried to participate in shaping into something I as an > operator believe useful in SIDR WG, but to no avail -- IMO because the > protocol work, and then the requirements work, were largely completed > already. I believe this approach will cause more harm than good and result in > more instability than security, and it leaves some considerable holes with > which I am actually concerned about related to inter-domain routing security > (and autonomy) on the Internet. As such, myself and some other operators > published this document, which has since been accepted and evolved as a > WG document within the Global Routing Operations WG (GROW): > > http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-grow-simple-leak-attack-bgpsec-no- > help-02 > > I've given up on SIDR, I wish them well.. +1 Russ