On 09/02/2013 03:55, John C Klensin wrote: ... > My personal instincts as an author run somewhat closer to > Melinda's criterion than to Don's but my bigger concern is that > trying to make specific rules about this will result in an > extended rat hole tour that ends up with rules that don't work > well for edge cases we don't anticipate. In complete violation of the spirit of draft-resnick-on-consensus, I will limit my comment to +1. Can we discuss something technical, please? Brian