Hi Stewart. Charter generally looks good to me. On the milestones, however: > Milestones: > Dec 2012 Problem Statement submitted for IESG review > Dec 2012 Framework document submitted for IESG review > Dec 2012 Data plane requirements submitted for IESG review > Dec 2012 Operational Requirements submitted for IESG review > Mar 2012 Control plane requirements submitted for IESG review > Mar 2012 Gap Analysis submitted for IESG review > Apr 2012 Recharter or close Working Group You presumably mean 2013 for the last 3. That said, I really hope the WG can get all of its documents to the IESG by December. That gives the WG 7-8 months and 2 IETF meetings. Not an easy task, but if it takes the WG a full year before it gets to doing anything beyond requirements, etc., that does not paint a very encouraging picture. I recall during the BOF someone (Jon Hudson?) stating that industry is already well ahead of the IETF in this space... Thomas