Hi Mykyta,
At 09:21 17-08-2011, Mykyta Yevstifeyev wrote:
IANA commented that it should be clear that "the registry" refers to
SMTP Service
Extensions (http://www.iana.org/assignments/mail-parameters); but
the registry there
From the write-up:
The entry in the SMTP Service Extensions registry for RFC 4409 should
be updated to reference this document. The reference for Submit (RFC
2476) should be updated to point to this document. The registry
should be updated to reflect the changed and new entries in Section 7.
"the registry" in the above should be read as "the SMTP Service
Extensions registry".
seems to have other format compared to Table 1:
+------------------+------------------+-----------+-----------------+
| Keyword | Name | Submissio | Reference |
| | | n | |
please compare with
Keywords Description Reference Note
So how is this table going to be incorporated in the aforementioned registry?
The following extract is from Section 7.1 of RFC 2476:
RFC Name Submission Reference
---- --------------- ---------- ------------------
2197 Pipelining SHOULD [PIPELINING]
2034 Error Codes SHOULD [CODES-EXTENSION]
1985 ETRN MUST NOT [ETRN]
This is from Section 7.1 of RFC 4409:
Keyword Name Submission Reference
---------- -------------------------- ---------- ----------------
PIPELINING Pipelining SHOULD [PIPELINING]
ENHANCEDSTATUSCODES Enhanced Status Codes SHOULD [CODES-EXTENSION]
ETRN Extended Turn MUST NOT [ETRN]
And finally from Section 7.1 of draft-ietf-yam-rfc4409bis-02:
| Keyword | Name | Submissio | Reference |
| | | n | |
+------------------+------------------+-----------+-----------------+
| PIPELINING | Pipelining | SHOULD | [PIPELINING] |
| ENHANCEDSTATUSCO | Enhanced Status | SHOULD | [CODES-EXTENSIO |
| DES | Codes | | N] |
| ETRN | Extended Turn | MUST NOT | [ETRN] |
The table has been in two previous RFCs. It was not a problem
then. It should not be a problem now. Section 10 of the draft
mentions how the table is going to be incorporated. The document
editors will follow up on this editorial matter.
Regards,
S. Moonesamy
_______________________________________________
Ietf mailing list
Ietf@xxxxxxxx
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf