On 1/6/21 10:13 AM, Michael Thomas wrote:
I disagree. Most of the time the soi-disant "generalilsts" are just self-aggrandizing and like to hear themselves speak. I remember when we were creating the DKIM working group we had a whole bunch of them and their "input" ended up contributing nothing at all other than delay.
There are also plenty of people in IETF, who aren't generalists, who like to hear themselves speak.
DKIM, or anything that remotely had to do with thwarting spam, may have been atypical. So many people are burned by spam and have naive ideas about how to address it, that such groups attract a lot of contributors with widely varying levels of expertise. And unfortunately, there's a broad tendency within IETF to disregard the input of anyone and everyone who wants to address that problem and has even a slightly different idea. But I don't think such groups are representative of the whole.
Keith
