Christian has expressed much of my position, with the exception of the following: IMO - protocols MUST NOT limit how IDs are selected or used. The issue isn’t the protocol spec; it’s the implementation. I.e., an *implementation* MAY do so. These recommendations MAY be useful, to that end. What I want to avoid is breaking the potential for IoT devices to use these protocols simply because they can’t implement the approaches described here. I also want to avoid a receiver saying “hey, sender, you picked the IDs badly, so I won’t connect to you”. That’s where I worry this is headed, and want to avoid. Joe |
-- last-call mailing list last-call@xxxxxxxx https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/last-call
