Gina,
your trace shows that your GnuGk 2.3.0 gives up on the call after
receiving the LocationReject from GK2 (207.x.x.x) and doesn't wait for
an answer from GK1 (192.x.x.x). Is GK1 where the call is supposed to
connect ?
That seems like a bug and I don't see that behaviour when I test with a
GnuGk 2.3.5 here. Please try again with GnuGk 2.3.5 and let us know if
that fixed the problem.
Regards,
Jan
Gina Bull wrote:
> Rats. I put in the "AcceptNonNeighborLRQ=1" and changed the "always" to "depends" but the connection
> still gets refused. And the Cisco still works (I used it to confirm that the site is still up. I'm
> really starting to resent that box ...)
>
> I'm appending a piece of the log from yesterday that shows what I think are the relevant entries. It
> looks to me like the Internet 2 gatekeeper is responding "not registered". (But the same GDS call
> when registered to the old Cisco worked.)
>
> (Also -- I'm getting help from our "master sysadmin" to get v.2.3.5 available so I can try that)
>
> Gina
> ----------
> Gina Bull
> Network System Engineer
> University of Virginia - ITS Network Systems
> PO Box 400324, 2015 Ivy Road, Charlottesville, VA 22904
>
>
>
> Caller is 128.143.13.168
> Destination is 0018128554673 via GDS
> This gatekeeper name is UVaGK1 (128.143.2.121)
>
> 2011/11/07 09:16:10.247 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent Successful
> 2011/11/07 09:16:10.247 5 job.cxx(427) JOB Job RRQ deleted
> 2011/11/07 09:16:10.247 5 job.cxx(416) JOB Worker threads: 5 total - 3 busy, 2 idle
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.844 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.844 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.844 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 128.143.13.168:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.844 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> admissionRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 32778
> callType = pointToPoint <<null>>
> callModel = gatekeeperRouted <<null>>
> endpointIdentifier = 16 characters {
> 0038 0031 0043 0038 0042 0043 0038 0043 81C8BC8C
> 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0041 0000000A
> }
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=dialedDigits "0018128554673"
> }
> srcInfo = 2 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 12 characters {
> 0054 0045 0053 0054 0020 0049 0054 0053 TEST ITS
> 0020 0050 0056 0058 PVX
> }
> [1]=dialedDigits "00117995371"
> }
> bandWidth = 7680
> callReferenceValue = 27920
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c6 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> activeMC = FALSE
> answerCall = FALSE
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c5 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> }
> gatekeeperIdentifier = 6 characters {
> 0055 0056 0061 0047 004b 0031 UVaGK1
> }
> willSupplyUUIEs = FALSE
> featureSet = {
> replacementFeatureSet = FALSE
> supportedFeatures = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> id = standard 9
> }
> }
> }
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.844 5 job.cxx(364) JOB Worker threads: 5 total - 4 busy, 1 idle
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.844 5 job.cxx(190) JOB Starting Job ARQ at Worker thread
> 139841453688576
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 1 RasSrv.cxx(368) RAS ARQ Received from 128.143.13.168:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 3 RasSrv.cxx(2466) GK ARQ will request bandwith of 7680
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 5 Routing.h(177) ROUTING Checking policy Neighbor for the
> request ARQ 32778
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 3 RasSrv.cxx(250) RAS Send to 192.148.244.130:1719
> locationRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 1229
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=dialedDigits "0018128554673"
> }
> nonStandardData = {
> nonStandardIdentifier = h221NonStandard {
> t35CountryCode = 181
> t35Extension = 0
> manufacturerCode = 18
> }
> data = 57 octets {
> 82 03 90 11 00 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c5 d3 ......5PU.......
> 10 09 0e 2f 3d 23 02 40 0b 00 54 00 45 00 53 00 .../=#.@..T.E.S.
> 54 00 20 00 49 00 54 00 53 00 20 00 50 00 56 00 T. .I.T.S. .P.V.
> 58 05 00 33 44 ac c8 6a 40 X..3D..j@
> }
> }
> replyAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 80 8f 02 79 ...y
> }
> port = 1719
> }
> sourceInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 6 characters {
> 0055 0056 0061 0047 004b 0031 UVaGK1
> }
> }
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> hopCount = 5
> canMapSrcAlias = FALSE
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent Successful
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 3 RasSrv.cxx(250) RAS Send to 207.75.164.39:1719
> locationRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 1229
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=dialedDigits "0018128554673"
> }
> nonStandardData = {
> nonStandardIdentifier = h221NonStandard {
> t35CountryCode = 181
> t35Extension = 0
> manufacturerCode = 18
> }
> data = 57 octets {
> 82 03 90 11 00 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c5 d3 ......5PU.......
> 10 09 0e 2f 3d 23 02 40 0b 00 54 00 45 00 53 00 .../=#.@..T.E.S.
> 54 00 20 00 49 00 54 00 53 00 20 00 50 00 56 00 T. .I.T.S. .P.V.
> 58 05 00 33 44 ac c8 6a 40 X..3D..j@
> }
> }
> replyAddress = ipAddress {
> ip = 4 octets {
> 80 8f 02 79 ...y
> }
> port = 1719
> }
> sourceInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 6 characters {
> 0055 0056 0061 0047 004b 0031 UVaGK1
> }
> }
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> hopCount = 5
> canMapSrcAlias = FALSE
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent Successful
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.845 2 Neighbor.cxx(916) NB 2 LRQ(s) sent
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.863 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.863 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.863 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 207.75.164.39:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.863 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> requestInProgress {
> requestSeqNum = 1229
> delay = 60000
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.863 2 RasSrv.cxx(1393) RAS Trapped RIP
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.863 5 Neighbor.cxx(963) NB Received RIP message matched pending
> LRQ for neighbor GK1:192.148.244.130
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.986 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.986 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.987 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 207.75.164.39:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.987 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> locationReject {
> requestSeqNum = 1229
> rejectReason = notRegistered <<null>>
> genericData = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> id = nonStandard 16 octets {
> 65 cd 7b 8a dc 67 11 db be d4 00 12 3f 63 4b 1d e.{..g......?cK.
> }
> parameters = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> id = nonStandard 16 octets {
> 65 cd 7b 8b dc 67 11 db be d4 00 12 3f 63 4b 1d e.{..g......?cK.
> }
> content = number32 18
> }
> }
> }
> }
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.987 2 RasSrv.cxx(1393) RAS Trapped LRJ
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.987 5 Neighbor.cxx(963) NB Received LRJ message matched pending
> LRQ for neighbor GK1:192.148.244.130
> 2011/11/07 09:16:12.987 5 Neighbor.cxx(998) NB LRQ rejected for neighbor
> GK1:192.148.244.130
> 2011/11/07 09:16:17.844 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:17.845 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:17.845 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 128.143.13.168:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:17.845 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> admissionRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 32778
> callType = pointToPoint <<null>>
> callModel = gatekeeperRouted <<null>>
> endpointIdentifier = 16 characters {
> 0038 0031 0043 0038 0042 0043 0038 0043 81C8BC8C
> 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0041 0000000A
> }
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=dialedDigits "0018128554673"
> }
> srcInfo = 2 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 12 characters {
> 0054 0045 0053 0054 0020 0049 0054 0053 TEST ITS
> 0020 0050 0056 0058 PVX
> }
> [1]=dialedDigits "00117995371"
> }
> bandWidth = 7680
> callReferenceValue = 27920
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c6 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> activeMC = FALSE
> answerCall = FALSE
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c5 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> }
> gatekeeperIdentifier = 6 characters {
> 0055 0056 0061 0047 004b 0031 UVaGK1
> }
> willSupplyUUIEs = FALSE
> featureSet = {
> replacementFeatureSet = FALSE
> supportedFeatures = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> id = standard 9
> }
> }
> }
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:17.845 2 RasSrv.cxx(1382) RAS Duplicate ARQ, deleted
> 2011/11/07 09:16:22.840 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:22.840 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:22.840 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 128.143.13.168:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:22.840 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> admissionRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 32778
> callType = pointToPoint <<null>>
> callModel = gatekeeperRouted <<null>>
> endpointIdentifier = 16 characters {
> 0038 0031 0043 0038 0042 0043 0038 0043 81C8BC8C
> 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0041 0000000A
> }
> destinationInfo = 1 entries {
> [0]=dialedDigits "0018128554673"
> }
> srcInfo = 2 entries {
> [0]=h323_ID 12 characters {
> 0054 0045 0053 0054 0020 0049 0054 0053 TEST ITS
> 0020 0050 0056 0058 PVX
> }
> [1]=dialedDigits "00117995371"
> }
> bandWidth = 7680
> callReferenceValue = 27920
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c6 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> activeMC = FALSE
> answerCall = FALSE
> canMapAlias = TRUE
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c5 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> }
> gatekeeperIdentifier = 6 characters {
> 0055 0056 0061 0047 004b 0031 UVaGK1
> }
> willSupplyUUIEs = FALSE
> featureSet = {
> replacementFeatureSet = FALSE
> supportedFeatures = 1 entries {
> [0]={
> id = standard 9
> }
> }
> }
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:22.840 2 RasSrv.cxx(1382) RAS Duplicate ARQ, deleted
> 2011/11/07 09:16:24.340 3 RasTbl.cxx(494) Gk Delete endpoint: 81C8BC8C0000000A 0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:24.340 3 RasTbl.cxx(494) Gk Delete endpoint: 6489_endp 0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 128.143.13.168:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> disengageRequest {
> requestSeqNum = 32779
> endpointIdentifier = 16 characters {
> 0038 0031 0043 0038 0042 0043 0038 0043 81C8BC8C
> 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0030 0041 0000000A
> }
> conferenceID = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c6 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> callReferenceValue = 27920
> disengageReason = normalDrop <<null>>
> callIdentifier = {
> guid = 16 octets {
> 02 35 50 55 05 0b de 1c 14 c5 d3 10 09 0e 2f 3d .5PU........../=
> }
> }
> gatekeeperIdentifier = 6 characters {
> 0055 0056 0061 0047 004b 0031 UVaGK1
> }
> answeredCall = FALSE
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 5 job.cxx(364) JOB Worker threads: 5 total - 5 busy, 0 idle
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 5 job.cxx(190) JOB Starting Job DRQ at Worker thread
> 139841453954816
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 1 RasSrv.cxx(368) RAS DRQ Received from 128.143.13.168:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 4 RasSrv.cxx(2832) GK DRQ: closed conference
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 2 RasSrv.cxx(408)
> DCF|128.143.13.168|81C8BC8C0000000A|27920|normalDrop|02-35-50-55-05-0b-de-1c-14-c5-d3-10-09-0e-2f-3d;
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 3 RasSrv.cxx(250) RAS Send to 128.143.13.168:1719
> disengageConfirm {
> requestSeqNum = 32779
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent Successful
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 5 job.cxx(427) JOB Job DRQ deleted
> 2011/11/07 09:16:26.156 5 job.cxx(416) JOB Worker threads: 5 total - 4 busy, 1 idle
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 yasocket.cxx(782) RasSrv 1 sockets selected from 4, total 4/0
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 4 RasSrv.cxx(230) RAS Receiving on 128.143.2.121:1719(U)
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 2 RasSrv.cxx(189) RAS Read from 192.148.244.130:1719
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 3 RasSrv.cxx(238) RAS
> locationReject {
> requestSeqNum = 1229
> rejectReason = requestDenied <<null>>
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 2 RasSrv.cxx(1393) RAS Trapped LRJ
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 Neighbor.cxx(963) NB Received LRJ message matched pending
> LRQ for neighbor GK2:207.75.164.39
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 Neighbor.cxx(998) NB LRQ rejected for neighbor
> GK2:207.75.164.39
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 Routing.h(177) ROUTING Checking policy Explicit for the
> request ARQ 32778
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 Routing.h(177) ROUTING Checking policy Internal for the
> request ARQ 32778
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 2 RasSrv.cxx(408)
> ARJ|128.143.13.168:1720|0018128554673:dialedDigits|TEST ITS
> PVX:h323_ID=00117995371:dialedDigits|false|calledPartyNotRegistered|02-35-50-55-05-0b-de-1c-14-c5-d3-10-09-0e-2f-3d;
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 3 RasSrv.cxx(250) RAS Send to 128.143.13.168:1719
> admissionReject {
> requestSeqNum = 32778
> rejectReason = calledPartyNotRegistered <<null>>
> }
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 RasSrv.cxx(264) RAS Sent Successful
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 job.cxx(427) JOB Job ARQ deleted
> 2011/11/07 09:16:30.986 5 job.cxx(416) JOB Worker threads: 5 total - 3 busy, 2 idle
>
>
> On 11/8/2011 11:49 AM, Jan Willamowius wrote:
> > You might need both. A look into your trace should tell you if the LRQ
> > for the inbound call that fails is coming from a direct neighbor or not.
> >
> > Also, with ForwardLRQ=always its rather easy to create LRQ loops. I
> > would leave it as "depends" unless you are really sure you need
> > otherwise.
> >
> > Regards,
> > Jan
> >
> > Gina Bull wrote:
> >> Oooo. Here is what I had put in:
> >>
> >> [RasSrv::LRQFeatures]
> >> AcceptNonNeighborLCF=1
> >>
> >> Did I confuse LCF with LRQ, or do I need both?
> >>
> >> Gina
> >>
> >> On 11/8/2011 11:25 AM, Jan Willamowius wrote:
> >>> Hi Gina,
> >>>
> >>> I think GDS might need a switch to accept non-neighbor LRQs:
> >>>
> >>> [RasSrv::LRQFeatures]
> >>> AcceptNonNeighborLRQ=1
> >>>
> >>> But you really should check the logs at which point the incoming call
> >>> fails.
> >>>
> >>> Also, if you are installing a fresh GnuGk, you shouldn't start with an
> >>> old version. I would suggest you use the last release 2.3.5. That
> >>> probably won't fix your current issue, but why keep all the old bugs in
> >>> place that we have already fixed during the last couple of years ?
> >>>
> >>> Regards,
> >>> Jan
> >>>
> >>
> >
> >
>
--
Jan Willamowius, jan@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx, http://www.gnugk.org/
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
RSA(R) Conference 2012
Save $700 by Nov 18
Register now
http://p.sf.net/sfu/rsa-sfdev2dev1
_______________________________________________________
Posting: mailto:Openh323gk-users@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Archive: http://sourceforge.net/mailarchive/forum.php?forum_name=openh323gk-users
Unsubscribe: http://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/openh323gk-users
Homepage: http://www.gnugk.org/
