On Čt, 2012-09-06 at 09:57 -0700, Adam Williamson wrote: > On 2012-09-06 0:59, Kamil Paral wrote: > >> Hi, > >> > >> Because of changes in package set selection in new anaconda, I > >> propose > >> to amend the alpha criterion: > >> > >> 'The installer must be able to complete package installation with > >> the > >> default package set for each supported installation method' > >> > >> to: > >> > >> 'The installer must be able to install the default desktop for each > >> supported installation method (DVD, live, netinst, PXE, ...)' > >> > >> I chose default desktop because in f17 every installation method had > >> it > >> as default package set. > > > > It makes sense to adjust it, because there is no longer "default" > > package set. Also big thanks for clarifying what "installation > > methods" mean. > > Do we know if it's *intended* that there's no default package set, or > is that a bug? It only makes sense to amend the criterion if the lack of > a default package set is actually intended. Also, if it's intended that > there's no default package set, can there be said to be a 'default > desktop' any more? GNOME is only the 'default' in that it's the desktop > in the 'default package set'. If there's no 'default package set', GNOME > becomes simply a choice on the package set selection screen, co-equal > with all the others. I can't see how it can be called 'the default'. > > > I wonder - we require only the default desktop (GNOME) to be > > installable, but we have further Alpha criteria for other > > release-blocking desktops (KDE)? That's funny :-) > > > Maybe we should say: > > 'The installer must be able to (successfully) install *all > > release-blocking desktops* for each supported installation method > > (DVD, live, netinst, PXE, ...)' > > I think that's better, if we assume the new behaviour in anaconda is > actually intended. There is no default 'package set' now (by design, it's not a bug). User has to choose something, so we can use the Kamil's version. It seems to me reasonable to require installation of release blocking desktops in Alpha phase. -- test mailing list test@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe: https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/test
