Hi, On Fri, May 15, 2020 at 02:12:00PM -0400, Charalampos Stratakis wrote: > Hello everyone, > > As of Python 3.8, python C extensions modules should not link to libpython, unless they embed the interpreter in their code. Relevant upstream PR: https://github.com/python/cpython/pull/12946 > If your package links to libpython without requiring it, it won't be possible to use the python3-debug binary with your python C extension, unless you recompile the extension against it. > > On Fedora Rawhide, there are at this point 144 packages linking to libpython, many of those possibly without any need for it. > > If your package links to libpython but it does not embed the interpreter, I would like to ask you to unlink it. Usually the fix needs to be done at the package's build system. > > If you are not sure if your package links to libpython, a way to figure this out is to inspect the code for the Py_Initialize and the Py_Finalize calls [0]. If the code includes those calls, no action is required from your side. If it does not, linking to libpython is not required. > > I might mass file bugzillas at a later date, but I wanted to provide you the heads up before that. > > [0] https://docs.python.org/3/c-api/init.html#initializing-and-finalizing-the-interpreter > > List of possibly affected packages, provided through $ repoquery --repo=rawhide --source --whatrequires 'libpython3.8.so.1.0()(64bit)' > > Maintainers by package: > > COPASI sagitter > HepMC3 ellert > Io-language limb > OpenImageIO hobbes1069 > PyQt4 rdieter than > YafaRay luya roma slaanesh > apbs rathann sagitter > babeltrace2 mjeanson > blender design-sw hobbes1069 ignatenkobrain kwizart luya roma s4504kr slaanesh > boost denisarnaud jwakely > calamares kkofler mattia > calibre chkr heliocastro kevin nushio zbyszek > cantor jreznik rdieter than > ceph adeza branto dmick ke4qqq kkeithle ktdreyer steve stingray > clingo thofmann > collectd fab kevin mhlavink ruben xaeth > condor bbockelm bcotton eerlands matt matyas stevetraylen tstclair ttheisen valtri > createrepo_c dmach jrohel mblaha pkratoch tmlcoch > csound pbrobinson sdz > cvc4 brouhaha jjames > dionaea rebus > dmlite adev andreamanzi gbitzes okeeble rocha > fontforge frixxon kevin pnemade > freecad hobbes1069 jkastner zultron > gdb jankratochvil keiths kevinb sergiodj > gdcm ankursinha ignatenkobrain mrceresa sebp > gdl orion > getdp ignatenkobrain smani > glade kalev > globus-net-manager ellert > glom hguemar > gnucash notting > gnuradio jskarvad mmahut > gpaw marcindulak > gplugin ignatenkobrain > gr-air-modes jskarvad > gr-fcdproplus jskarvad > gr-hpsdr jskarvad > gr-iqbal jskarvad > gr-osmosdr cottsay jskarvad > gr-rds jskarvad sharkcz > hamlib hobbes1069 jskarvad lucilanga > hexchat ohaessler tingping > hokuyoaist rmattes > hugin bpostle cicku denisarnaud > insight lkundrak monnerat > kdevelop-python dvratil jgrulich minh > kernel-tools jcline jforbes jwboyer labbott pbrobinson > kicad avigne coremodule lkundrak stevenfalco tnorth > kig jreznik kkofler rdieter > kitty atim > krita heliocastro rdieter > lammps ellio167 junghans > ldns pemensik pwouters thozza > libCombine sagitter > libarcus churchyard gferon > libarcus-lulzbot spot > libbatch smani > libcec pbrobinson > libcomps akozumpl dmach jluza jmracek mblaha pkratoch > libdnf dmach jmracek jrohel mblaha pkratoch > libftdi hobbes1069 lucilanga > libkml smani > libkolabxml tpokorra > libldb abbra asn gd iboukris jhrozek lslebodn sgallagh simo > libnuml sagitter > libpeas amigadave hadess nacho > libplist hadess pbrobinson > libreoffice caolanm dtardon erack sbergmann > librepo dmach pkratoch tmlcoch > libsavitar churchyard gferon > libsbml sagitter zbyszek > libsedml sagitter > libsigrokdecode mrnuke > libtalloc asn gd iboukris jhrozek lslebodn sgallagh simo > libyang tkorbar > libyui-bindings makowski ngompa tpokorra > link-grammar devos fabiand limb > lldb airlied daveisfera jankratochvil sergesanspaille siddharths tstellar > mapserver devrim jujens oliver pali > mathgl deji krege mycae > med smani > mod_wsgi jdornak jkaluza jorton lmacken mrunge > mraa pbrobinson > nautilus-python dignan genodeftest kalev > nbdkit rjones > nemo-extensions jcpunk leigh123linux > nest ankursinha > netgen-mesher hobbes1069 smani > neuron ankursinha > nextpnr lkundrak somlo > nordugrid-arc ellert jonkni > nwchem marcindulak > openbabel itamarjp jussilehtola rathann > openscap isimluk jcerny matyc mpreisle pvrabec wsato > opentrep denisarnaud > openvdb luya slaanesh > orocos-kdl thofmann > pam_wrapper asn jhrozek > paraview deji orion sagitter > perl-Inline-Python jonkni > pidgin jskarvad mcrha nosnilmot > pitivi company elad ignatenkobrain limb wtaymans > plplot orion > postgresql hhorak jstanek panovotn pkajaba pkubat praiskup tgl > pynac pcpa tomspur > pyotherside m4rtink > pythia8 ellert > python-caja monnerat raveit65 > python-graph-tool ankursinha > python-gstreamer1 farnz wtaymans > python-jep raphgro > python-qt5 rdieter than > qgis bruno volter > qpid-dispatch irina tross > qpid-proton irina > rdkit giallu > rdma-core dledford honli jwilson > renderdoc gicmo > rmol denisarnaud > root ellert > samba abbra anoopcs asn gd iboukris jarrpa jlayton jstephen obnox simo > scidavis alexpl > scribus pwalter sharkcz tripledes > sigil sharkcz > sourcextractor++ aalvarez > swift-lang tachoknight > syslog-ng czanik jpo mrunge > texworks cheeselee > thunarx-python balajig8 kevin nonamedotc > trademgen denisarnaud > trellis lkundrak somlo > unbound aegorenk akhaitov pavlix pemensik pwouters thozza > upm pbrobinson > uwsgi kad git grep on the source code does show usage of both Py_Initialize and Finalize calls, it embeds the interpreter in the python plugin (of course) > vapoursynth slaanesh > vdr-epg-daemon martinkg > vigra bpostle > vim karsten zdohnal > vrpn bizdelnick > vtk jgu mrceresa orion > weechat asrob gchamoul hguemar niveusluna stingray > znc elyscape nb > > Packages by maintainer: > aalvarez sourcextractor++ > abbra libldb samba > adev dmlite > adeza ceph > aegorenk unbound > airlied lldb > akhaitov unbound > akozumpl libcomps > alexpl scidavis > amigadave libpeas > andreamanzi dmlite > ankursinha gdcm nest neuron python-graph-tool > anoopcs samba > asn libldb libtalloc pam_wrapper samba > asrob weechat > atim kitty > avigne kicad > balajig8 thunarx-python > bbockelm condor > bcotton condor > bizdelnick vrpn > bpostle hugin vigra > branto ceph > brouhaha cvc4 > bruno qgis > caolanm libreoffice > cheeselee texworks > chkr calibre > churchyard libarcus libsavitar > cicku hugin > company pitivi > coremodule kicad > cottsay gr-osmosdr > czanik syslog-ng > daveisfera lldb > deji mathgl paraview > denisarnaud boost hugin opentrep rmol trademgen > design-sw blender > devos link-grammar > devrim mapserver > dignan nautilus-python > dledford rdma-core > dmach createrepo_c libcomps libdnf librepo > dmick ceph > dtardon libreoffice > dvratil kdevelop-python > eerlands condor > elad pitivi > ellert HepMC3 globus-net-manager nordugrid-arc pythia8 root > ellio167 lammps > elyscape znc > erack libreoffice > fab collectd > fabiand link-grammar > farnz python-gstreamer1 > frixxon fontforge > gbitzes dmlite > gchamoul weechat > gd libldb libtalloc samba > genodeftest nautilus-python > gferon libarcus libsavitar > giallu rdkit > gicmo renderdoc > hadess libpeas libplist > heliocastro calibre krita > hguemar glom weechat > hhorak postgresql > hobbes1069 OpenImageIO blender freecad hamlib libftdi netgen-mesher > honli rdma-core > iboukris libldb libtalloc samba > ignatenkobrain blender gdcm getdp gplugin pitivi > irina qpid-dispatch qpid-proton > isimluk openscap > itamarjp openbabel > jankratochvil gdb lldb > jarrpa samba > jcerny openscap > jcline kernel-tools > jcpunk nemo-extensions > jdornak mod_wsgi > jforbes kernel-tools > jgrulich kdevelop-python > jgu vtk > jhrozek libldb libtalloc pam_wrapper > jjames cvc4 > jkaluza mod_wsgi > jkastner freecad > jlayton samba > jluza libcomps > jmracek libcomps libdnf > jonkni nordugrid-arc perl-Inline-Python > jorton mod_wsgi > jpo syslog-ng > jreznik cantor kig > jrohel createrepo_c libdnf > jskarvad gnuradio gr-air-modes gr-fcdproplus gr-hpsdr gr-iqbal gr-osmosdr gr-rds hamlib pidgin > jstanek postgresql > jstephen samba > jujens mapserver > junghans lammps > jussilehtola openbabel > jwakely boost > jwboyer kernel-tools > jwilson rdma-core > kad uwsgi > kalev glade nautilus-python > karsten vim > ke4qqq ceph > keiths gdb > kevin calibre collectd fontforge thunarx-python > kevinb gdb > kkeithle ceph > kkofler calamares kig > krege mathgl > ktdreyer ceph > kwizart blender > labbott kernel-tools > leigh123linux nemo-extensions > limb Io-language link-grammar pitivi > lkundrak insight kicad nextpnr trellis > lmacken mod_wsgi > lslebodn libldb libtalloc > lucilanga hamlib libftdi > luya YafaRay blender openvdb > m4rtink pyotherside > makowski libyui-bindings > marcindulak gpaw nwchem > martinkg vdr-epg-daemon > matt condor > mattia calamares > matyas condor > matyc openscap > mblaha createrepo_c libcomps libdnf > mcrha pidgin > mhlavink collectd > minh kdevelop-python > mjeanson babeltrace2 > mmahut gnuradio > monnerat insight python-caja > mpreisle openscap > mrceresa gdcm vtk > mrnuke libsigrokdecode > mrunge mod_wsgi syslog-ng > mycae mathgl > nacho libpeas > nb znc > ngompa libyui-bindings > niveusluna weechat > nonamedotc thunarx-python > nosnilmot pidgin > notting gnucash > nushio calibre > obnox samba > ohaessler hexchat > okeeble dmlite > oliver mapserver > orion gdl paraview plplot vtk > pali mapserver > panovotn postgresql > pavlix unbound > pbrobinson csound kernel-tools libcec libplist mraa upm > pcpa pynac > pemensik ldns unbound > pkajaba postgresql > pkratoch createrepo_c libcomps libdnf librepo > pkubat postgresql > pnemade fontforge > praiskup postgresql > pvrabec openscap > pwalter scribus > pwouters ldns unbound > raphgro python-jep > rathann apbs openbabel > raveit65 python-caja > rdieter PyQt4 cantor kig krita python-qt5 > rebus dionaea > rjones nbdkit > rmattes hokuyoaist > rocha dmlite > roma YafaRay blender > ruben collectd > s4504kr blender > sagitter COPASI apbs libCombine libnuml libsbml libsedml paraview > sbergmann libreoffice > sdz csound > sebp gdcm > sergesanspaille lldb > sergiodj gdb > sgallagh libldb libtalloc > sharkcz gr-rds scribus sigil > siddharths lldb > simo libldb libtalloc samba > slaanesh YafaRay blender openvdb vapoursynth > smani getdp libbatch libkml med netgen-mesher > somlo nextpnr trellis > spot libarcus-lulzbot > steve ceph > stevenfalco kicad > stevetraylen condor > stingray ceph weechat > tachoknight swift-lang > tgl postgresql > than PyQt4 cantor python-qt5 > thofmann clingo orocos-kdl > thozza ldns unbound > tingping hexchat > tkorbar libyang > tmlcoch createrepo_c librepo > tnorth kicad > tomspur pynac > tpokorra libkolabxml libyui-bindings > tripledes scribus > tross qpid-dispatch > tstclair condor > tstellar lldb > ttheisen condor > valtri condor > volter qgis > wsato openscap > wtaymans pitivi python-gstreamer1 > xaeth collectd > zbyszek calibre libsbml > zdohnal vim > zultron freecad > > -- > Regards, > > Charalampos Stratakis > Software Engineer > Python Maintenance Team, Red Hat -- Be braver -- you can't cross a chasm in two small jumps.
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: PGP signature
_______________________________________________ devel mailing list -- devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx To unsubscribe send an email to devel-leave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Fedora Code of Conduct: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/project/code-of-conduct/ List Guidelines: https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Mailing_list_guidelines List Archives: https://lists.fedoraproject.org/archives/list/devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
