Jeff Spaleta wrote: > On Fri, Jul 9, 2010 at 3:34 PM, Carl Gaudreault > <carl.gaudreault@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: >>>So It seems Carl G. has been closing several bugs across multiple >>>components without comment recently. Hmm. Not cool. >> >> -jef >> >> I gave the reason why i closed it. > > Are you saying that you comment in 27 requesting the report file a > report upstream bug in bug 531464 is meant to be taking as rationale > for closing the fedora ticket as WONTFIX? > > Its not clear from my reading of the comment that is your intention. > Nor is it clear to me that this is an appropriate best practise to do > in general even if this is what you intended. Doubly-so if the person > doing the closures isn't listed as a co-maintainer or an upstream > developer. > > I certainly leave bugs in an open state until I or one of my > co-maintainers makes a judgement call which mandates a wontfix > resolution. This looks like a real issue..a tough one to track > down..but still potentially fixable. Neither cantfix nor wontfix seem > to apply... nor does notabug. There's nothing here in the commentary > that suggests to me this is a wontfix situation if someone was able to > provide an upstreamable patch that could be integrated into our > packages. > > >> >> Also, RHBZ number you are referring to? > > Do you want a complete listing? I can talk to you about the pattern > of behaviour offlist. I have concerns about some of your other recent > wontifx/notabug closures. Your insufficient information closures seem > to be reasonable as well as more than reasonably justified in the > comments. > > -jef https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=531464#c29 >So It seems Carl G. has been closing several bugs across multiple >components without comment recently. Hmm. Not cool. Are you talking about the other bug report related to Empathy i reported months ago and was closed upstream? "several bugs across multiple components".. sure ;)
Attachment:
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
-- devel mailing list devel@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/devel
