Dear All, Can't we just go back to the way it was, with [$MAILING_LIST] in the subject line, re-write From: then sign the e-mail on the lists.archlinux.org server? That way DMARC and everyone's mail program could be made happy. Since we do not re-write the Subject: anymore I cannot separate the Arch list e-mail well anymore. Some (mobile) clients cannot mark or file mail as well as desktop clients can and everything ends up in one inbox. Just my 2 cents. Merry Christmas everyone! NTS On Mon, 26 Dec 2022 at 14:18, Polarian <polarian@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: > > Hello, > > So I have very strict DMARC settings on my domain, so I am aware I am > going to get a lot of warnings. > > I have used "include" in my spf record for polarian.dev to allow > lists.archlinux.org to redirect emails (because of mailing list), > however DMARC still fails. > > In most cases DKIM remains untouched, therefore passes, but in a select > few cases the DKIM signature was tampered with according to the reports > I have gotten back, which is very strange, I assume this is not > lists.archlinux.org fault but some people on the list use email proxies > which are probably not configured well. > > DKIM is not the issue though, SPF is. > > lists.archlinux.org is included, but yet spf still fails, upon further > inspection it seems lists.archlinux.org uses 2 different IPv4 addresses, > but only one is named in the SPF record, thus failing. > > Does anyone else have these issues with the arch linux mailing list? > > Thanks, > Polarian
