On Sat, 2010-06-19 at 19:36 +0800, Heherson Pagcaliwagan wrote: > 2010/6/19 Máirín Duffy <duffy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>: > > On Fri, 2010-06-18 at 19:38 -0500, Mike McGrath wrote: > >> > Is it not clear that the majority of the discussion here isn't about a > >> > single blog post? > >> > > >> > >> Reading it all at once, no it wasn't. What is the discussion about? > > > > While a single blog post sparked the discussion most of it has been > > about whether or not we should come up with guidelines for planet, how > > do we handle problematic posts, proposals to address some of the issues, > > things of that nature. We wouldn't have so much to talk about if there > > hadn't been several planet incidents in the past couple years or so. > > > > I would just like to report that (1) the planet feed of the blog in > question now implements tag filtering and (2) it just took a quick > email pointing the problem. The line about "Fedora Project's > contributors do attempt to resolve every such situation constructively > and amicably"[1] still holds true so it seems. > > Mo probably wants the discussion for "really sticky" situations where > the poster and the reporter stopped in "being excellent to each > other". So far, it's the purview of the Fedora Webmaster to make the > judgment call whether it infringes on the set guidelines or not. > > My vote is for us to keep being excellent to each other and probably > have a go at the guidelines using things we just have learned from a > post of an ambassador-to-be. > > [1] http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Planet Overall, I wasn't really offended by the post that provoked the current discussion, and I think that some of the concerns we have been raised are addressed by (a) the CLA+1 requirement and (b) the existing guidelines. One thing we should consider proactively is a way to quickly and temporarily remove a feed from the planet if there is a massively offensive post (porn, a profanity-laden diatribe, stolen proprietary source code, or whatever). Is it prudent to have a kill-and-consider procedure in place, with the sincere hope that we'd never need to invoke it? (Trust me, I really don't want more policies, monitoring, or censorship in place, but perhaps we do need a way to react quickly if something crazy happens). -Chris _______________________________________________ advisory-board mailing list advisory-board@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://admin.fedoraproject.org/mailman/listinfo/advisory-board
