Yep. Here are the answers. But i think that nothing of them is unsefull as a hint for this problem. a)ffmpeg: ffmpeg version(CVS) build(3344384) b) xv c) lcd via vga d) 1440x900 e) 16:10 Ihope that its usefull to resolve this bug. cheers, DaLiMan Stefan Lucke wrote: > On Mittwoch 03 Mai 2006 16:50, vdr@xxxxxxxxxx wrote: > >> I hope somebody help me again and translate the following. Thanks very much. >> >> Ich habe bisher Screen Aspect im SetupMen? auf 4:3 eingestellt. Daher >> erfolgte >> das automatische Umschalten bei einem 16:9 Stream nicht. Mit der Einstellung >> default funktioniert es. Das bedeutet da? dies kein Fehler ist. >> > > Ich hoffe, Du kannst die Antwort in Englisch verstehen. Wenn nicht, > so sollten wir das Off-List weiter diskutie > > Hups, you say switch works only when screen aspect is set to default, > and it doesn't work when screen aspect is set to 4:3. > If thats true, that would be a bug. But ... > > So lets collect some facts. > From your other bug report I know, that you are using latest vdr + softdevice. > Which ffmpeg version do you use (version number is printed at startup) ? > Which output method do you use ? > Do you connect a monitor via VGA out or a TV via TV out ? > When you are using VGA, what is the native resolution of your device ? > What is the native aspect ratio of your output device ? > > And then please provide a similar to the following information of your system, > when to your opinion the switch is handled wrong _and_ correct. > You'll find this information in the system log. > > With Xv out I see the following: > That is a switch from 4:3 to 16:9 video stream, screen aspect set to 4:3 > May 3 21:11:20 jarada jarada vdr: [10352] [VideoOut]: aspect changed (0 -> 0 ; 1.333333 -> 1.777778) > May 3 21:11:20 jarada jarada vdr: [10352] [VideoOut]: 720x576 [0,0 720x576] -> 768x576 [0,57 768x461] > > The same switch when screen aspect is set to default: > May 3 21:14:33 jarada jarada vdr: [10366] [VideoOut]: aspect changed (0 -> 0 ; 1.333333 -> 1.777778) > May 3 21:14:33 jarada jarada vdr: [10366] [VideoOut]: 720x576 [0,0 720x576] -> 768x576 [0,70 768x436] > > Still a bit wrong, as my LCD has an aspect ratio of 5:4. Now when set to 5:4: > May 3 21:16:36 jarada jarada vdr: [10380] [VideoOut]: aspect changed (0 -> 0 ; 1.333333 -> 1.777778) > May 3 21:16:36 jarada jarada vdr: [10380] [VideoOut]: 720x576 [0,0 720x576] -> 768x576 [0,72 768x432] > > That is from my test stream which has an AFD value set, which describes it > as 4:3 active format, even stream is in 16:9. Usual behaviour > would be a vertical downscale, but we cutout 90 pixel left and right > from source and display this at full display/window area of 768x576. > May 3 21:18:58 jarada jarada vdr: [10405] [VideoOut]: aspect changed (0 -> 9 ; 1.333333 -> 1.777778) > May 3 21:18:58 jarada jarada vdr: [10405] [VideoOut]: 720x576 [90,0 540x576] -> 768x576 [0,0 768x576] > > >> Ich >> m?chte f?r mich >> die automatische Umschaltung auf 16:9 auch bei ScreenAspect=4:3. F?r einen >> kleinen Tipp wo ich welche Variable setzen w?re ich dankbar. >> >> > > > >
