Thanks Roger, I appreciate your help and quick reply! Two of the disks (sda, sdb) were able to return # smartctl --all /dev/sdX just fine, but sdc and sdd returned very little, so I dug a bit deeper with # smartctl -d ata -T permissive --all /dev/sdX The results are in the pastebin: https://pastebin.com/yWJTPvBa It looks like only sdd has an error count. I would love to get this up long enough to recover at least a portion of the data, which isn't backed up elsewhere.