Comments on PF exhibit 2004-08-08

[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

 



>               Dan Mitchell - The Interrogation
http://www.rit.edu/~andpph/gallery/mitchell.html

I sometimes wonder if there are two Dan Mitchell's posting imaes to
the gallery.
Some, like this, I really take to: they are clearly photographer's
pictures.
Others, sorry Dan, I see as little more than local snapshots.

On this, I do like the simplicity: I do like the mystery (guessing it
is a chair within a gallery fo staff to sit on?).

Something I'm not sure about is some visual disturbance on the right
edge: it looks like gaussian blur has been applied to remove a
distracting notice board.  At least, that's my guess.  Is it so?  I
would have preferred - marginally - a different crop.
http://website.lineone.net/~wildimages/PF/mitchell-2.jpg

Was the board removed digitally?
Was it even a board?
Does the lens have flare? there is light bleed from the white room to
the green door).
Who chose the red and yellow carpet?


Was it gaussian blur?
I'm not now so sure.
Looking at the bas-relief version
http://website.lineone.net/~wildimages/PF/mitchell-3.jpg




>               Alan Zinn -
What more can I say: a quality panorama.
It could just as easily be a motor show in the UK, except for THAT
flag.  I mean, not the stars and stripes but the Union Jack that
"should" replace it in any translation.  It always srtikes me how
often the national flag appears in the bckground in the US while in
the UK we hardly ever see ours.  So much so that if I see it I notice.

This though is an example of a good use of the panoramic format.
Where are the thirds? Who gives a stuff.  There are three cars, does
that count?
One minor comment: for the trouble you took to get this shot could you
not have asked permission to move the sign temporarily while you took
it?  It's the only blot on an otherwise harmonious image - as seen
through my eyes ... or should I say, as seen projected withing my
head, where ultimately the whole would lives ;o)

Bob


[Index of Archives] [Share Photos] [Epson Inkjet] [Scanner List] [Gimp Users] [Gimp for Windows]

  Powered by Linux