On Wed, Nov 30, 2022 at 18:03 Mladen Gogala <gogala.mladen@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On 11/30/22 18:19, Hannes Erven wrote:
You could also use a filesystem that can do atomic snapshots - like ZFS.Uh, oh. Not so sure about that. Here is a page from the world of the big O: https://blog.docbert.org/oracle-on-zfs/
However, similar can be said about ZFS. ZFS snapshots will slow down the I/O considerably. I would definitely prefer snapshots done in hardware and not in software. My favorite file systems, depending on the type of disk, are F2FS and XFS.
ZFS snapshots don’t typically have much if any performance impact versus not having a snapshot (and already being on ZFS) because it’s already doing COW style semantics.
Postgres write performance using ZFS is difficult because it’s super important to match up the underlying I/O sizes to the device/ZFS ashift, the ZFS recordsize, and the DB’s page/wal page sizes though, but not getting this right also cause performance issues without any snapshots, because again COW. If you’re constantly breaking a record block or sector there’s going to be a big impact. It won’t be any worse (in my own testing) regardless of if you have snapshots or not. Snapshots on ZFS don’t cause any crazy write amplification by themselves (I’m not sure they cause any extra writes at all, I’d have to do some sleuthing)
ZFS will yes be slower than a raw disk (but that’s not an option for Pg anyway), and may or may not be faster than a different filesystem on a HW RAID volume or storage array volume. It absolutely takes more care/clue/tuning to get Pg write performance on ZFS, and ZFS does duplicate some of Pg’s resiliency so there is duplicate work going on.
I’d say really that 2016 article is meaningless as ZFS, Oracle, and Postgres have all evolved dramatically in six years. Even further since there’s nothing remotely like ASM for Postgres.
-- Mladen Gogala Database Consultant Tel: (347) 321-1217 https://dbwhisperer.wordpress.com
"Genius might be described as a supreme capacity for getting its possessors
into trouble of all kinds."
-- Samuel Butler
