> How can I know whether scatter/gather is available or not? > In another word, when it's available and when it's not? > I do not intend to ask the behavior of gadget driver. > I just wonder how I can confirm it in general. The following applies for device features in general, not just scatter/gather. Sometimes you get lucky, and the bus standard in use (PCI, USB, SPI/I2C, etc) mandates that the feature is supported in a standard way. So if you're writing a device driver for a specific card that uses a Wombat 9348j chipset, you'll probably need to get in touch with the company that makes the Wombat 9348j chipset and get the data sheet for it, and that will hopefully have the chipset programming details needed. If you're unlucky, the company won't give you the datasheet, or it won't contain the info, so you get to reverse engineer the chipset. One popular technique is to look at *other* chips in the Wombat 93 series, determine via some means whether those chipsets support scatter-gather, and how it's enabled. Then you put the same code in your driver, and see what happens. Possibility 1: Scatter-gather works just fine and the 16K I/O ends up in the 4 pages you allocated. Success! Possibility 2: It doesn't work,and the 16K of I/O hits your first 4K page, and the next 3 sequential pages even though they're something else, and your kernel crashes and burns because you just overlaid 12K worth of page tables or struct tasks or something important. Possibility 3: It doesn't work, but it takes you a while to find out because during your tests, the 4 pages happened to be allocated next to each other. It has happened that nobody notices until the driver is part of the mainline kernel, which is usually embarrassing... Possibility 4: It doesn't work, and the bit that says "use scatter/gather" in the IO command structure on the other chipsets actually enables the undocumented auto-defenestration capability of the chipset. This is usually worse than just embarrassing...
Attachment:
pgp00RxxcJvOY.pgp
Description: PGP signature
_______________________________________________ Kernelnewbies mailing list Kernelnewbies@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx https://lists.kernelnewbies.org/mailman/listinfo/kernelnewbies
