On Jun 7, 2011, at 12:04 PM, Jarod Wilson wrote: > On Jun 7, 2011, at 2:45 AM, Radim wrote: > >> >>> ------------ Pôvodná správa ------------ >>> Od: Jarod Wilson <jarod@xxxxxxxxxx> >>> Predmet: Re: Last key repeated after every keypress on remote control (saa7134 >>> lirc devinput driver) >>> Dátum: 06.6.2011 20:39:50 >>> ---------------------------------------- >>> Devin Heitmueller wrote: >>>> On Mon, Jun 6, 2011 at 2:13 PM, Radim<radim100@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: >>>>> Hello to everybody, >>>>> I was redirected here from lirc mailinglist (reason is at the end). >>>>> >>>>> I'm asking for any help because I wasn't able to solve >>>>> this problem by my self (and google of course). >>>>> >>>>> When I'm testing lirc configuration using irw, last pressed key is repeated >>>>> just befor the new one: >>>>> >>>>> after pressing key 1: >>>>> 0000000080010002 00 KEY_1 devinput >>>>> >>>>> after pressing key 2: >>>>> 0000000080010002 00 KEY_1 devinput >>>>> 0000000080010003 00 KEY_2 devinput >>>>> >>>>> after pressing key 3: >>>>> 0000000080010003 00 KEY_2 devinput >>>>> 0000000080010004 00 KEY_3 devinput >>>>> >>>>> after pressing key 4: >>>>> 0000000080010004 00 KEY_3 devinput >>>>> 0000000080010005 00 KEY_4 devinput >>>>> >>>>> after pressing key 5: >>>>> 0000000080010005 00 KEY_4 devinput >>>>> 0000000080010006 00 KEY_5 devinput >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> My configuration: >>>>> Archlinux (allways up-to-date) >>>>> Asus MyCinema P7131 with remote control PC-39 >>>>> lircd 0.9.0, driver devinput, default config file lirc.conf.devinput >>>>> kernel 2.6.38 >>>>> >>>>> # ir-keytable >>>>> Found /sys/class/rc/rc0/ (/dev/input/event5) with: >>>>> Driver saa7134, table rc-asus-pc39 >>>>> Supported protocols: NEC RC-5 RC-6 JVC SONY LIRC >>>>> Enabled protocols: RC-5 >>>>> Repeat delay = 500 ms, repeat period = 33 ms >>>>> >>>>> Answare from lirc-mainlinglist (Jarod Wilson): >>>>> Looks like a bug in saa7134-input.c, which doesn't originate in lirc land, >>>>> its from the kernel itself. The more apropos location to tackle this issue >>>>> is linux-media@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx. >>>>> >>>>> I can provide any other listings, just ask for them. >>>>> >>>>> Thank you for any help, >>>>> Radim >>>> >>>> I actually sent Jarod a board specifically to investigate this issue >>>> (the same issue occurs on the saa7134 based HVR-1150). I believe it's >>>> on his TODO list. >>> Yep, he chopped out the part of my reply where I said as much. :) >>> Just waiting on the IR receiver cable to arrive, could well be here in today's mail... >> >> Oh, I misunderstood Jarod answer - he pointed me to this list as a right place for posting this possible bug in saa7134 driver, so I sent it also here. I was thinking that this is not a job for member of lirc developers, so I was trying luck here.. > > I work on both lirc and media tree drivers. In this case, lircd is doing > exactly the right thing with the data its being fed, the bug is in the > kernel driver, which is from the media tree. Best to discuss the bug on > the list for the layer at which it exists. :) > > (No cable yet, still awaiting its arrival). Forgot to reply in this thread. Patch was posted last week that fixes the repeat problem on the HVR-1150 Devin sent me. Best as I can tell from looking at the saa7134 code and the particulars for your hardware, that fix should solve your repeat issue as well. -- Jarod Wilson jarod@xxxxxxxxxxxx -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-media" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
