Hi there,
actually I am using kernel 2.6.34, up to now I was in every (stable)
release since 2.6.30 affected by this issue.
Today I have reactivated legacy, regrettably deprecated parallel ATA
support and have disabled libata. Its a shame, libata is much faster
(about 20% faster I/O measureable) and more forward-looking, but it is
not a real alternative if it crashes continuous but not reproduceable on
via-chipsets (google for this, the web is filled of this issue!). I
know, via chipsets are not very good, but shouldn't we try to make it
better (or at least best as possible) with newer drivers instead of worse?
I hope legacy ATA support won't be removed soon from the kernel sources ...
I like trying out a lot, but if the response is so thin it does not make
fun just looking at the same issue with the same messages again and
again not able to do anything beside looking at it and resetting the box
afterwards ...
kind regards, Alois
--- Begin Message ---
Hi Mikael,
thanks for your response.
to 1.) If I stop limiting the harddisk to UDMA3 it will try to speak
every time UDMA4 - this does not work flawless and so there are a lot of
hard resets of the IDE-channel.
Is there another possibility to limit the drive to UDMA3? With
legacy-IDE I did this always with hdparm, but this does not work with
libata. :-/
to 2.) I cannot separate the two devices - the CF-port is soldered onto
the mainboard and is connected to the secodary master, the 2.5" harddisc
has a 44pin connector to the 44pin-connector on the mainbaord. :-/
kind regards, Alois
Mikael Pettersson wrote:
MadLoisae@xxxxxxx writes:
> Hello Jeff, hello linux-ide-team,
>
> I encounter here sometimes a strange problem - I hope you do not bother
> me that I write direct to you.
> I use following hardware: VT82C586A/B/VT82C686/A/B/VT823x/A/C PIPC Bus
> Master IDE (rev 06) as PATA-controller (so I use the pata_via module -
> 1106:0571), on the secondary channel as master a Compact Flash card, as
> slave a 2.5" WDC 320GB harddisc. The harddisc is only able to speak
> UDMA3 (caused by the cable), the Compact Flash Card is able to speak
> UDMA4. So I force this values with the kernel command line
> (libata.force=2.00:udma4,2.01:udma3). I am using ext3 on the FlashCard
> and ext4 on the harddisc, splitted in 4 partitions.
> I use linux 2.6.31.4, my config is attached.
> Since 2.6.30 I use libata instead of legacy IDE.
> After a not reproduceable time my machine is not able to handle my
> harddisk any more. There are always the same logs:
>
> [1036724.000131] ata2.01: exception Emask 0x0 SAct 0x0 SErr 0x0 action
> 0x6 frozen
> [1036724.000256] ata2.01: cmd c8/00:08:0b:72:04/00:00:00:00:00/fa tag 0
> dma 4096 in
> [1036724.000262] res 40/00:00:00:78:00/00:00:00:00:00/10 Emask
> 0x4 (timeout)
...
> at this time the only workaround is a reboot - i did not find any way
> yet to reanimate the harddisc in this state.
Two suggestions:
1. don't use libata.force
2. put the CF card and the PATA disk on separate channels with separate cables
--- End Message ---
