[repost. I didn´t notice autocompletion gave me wrong address for fsdevel, blacklisted now] Hello. What do you think of http://open-zfs.org/wiki/Projects/ZFS_Channel_Programs ? There are quite some BTRFS maintenance programs like the deduplication stuff. Also regular scrubs… and in certain circumstances probably balances can make sense. In addition to this XFS got scrub functionality as well. Now putting the foundation for such a functionality in the kernel I think would only be reasonable if it cannot be done purely within user space, so I wonder about the safety from other concurrent ZFS modification and atomicity that are mentioned on the wiki page. The second set of slides, those the OpenZFS Developer Commit 2014, which are linked to on the wiki page explain this more. (I didn´t look the first ones, as I am no fan of slideshare.net and prefer a simple PDF to download and view locally anytime, not for privacy reasons alone, but also to avoid a using a crappy webpage over a wonderfully functional PDF viewer fat client like Okular) Also I wonder about putting a lua interpreter into the kernel, but it seems at least NetBSD developers added one to their kernel with version 7.0¹. I also ask this cause I wondered about a kind of fsmaintd or volmaintd for quite a while, and thought… it would be nice to do this in a generic way, as BTRFS is not the only filesystem which supports maintenance operations. However if it can all just nicely be done in userspace, I am all for it. [1] http://www.netbsd.org/releases/formal-7/NetBSD-7.0.html (tons of presentation PDFs on their site as well) Thanks, -- Martin
