Am 15.07.2010 13:24, schrieb Louigi Verona:
On Thu, Jul 15, 2010 at 1:49 PM, James Stone<jamesmstone@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
I don't know Reason at all, but as far as I was aware, it was just a
sequencer with a synth and drums included in a monolithic piece of
software. With the exception of a lightweight sampler plugin, qtractor
can do all that using dssi or lv2 plugins and piano roll, with the
extra advantage of being able to record audio. As far as I am aware,
Lmms, Neil, Renoise and energyXT2 all have the same or better
functionality as Reason. The only difference I can see is the GFX and
the method of entering notes. Or am I missing something?
Well, you should go ahead and read up about Reason in wikipedia. Wired is
basically
a Reason clone. It is different to Qtractor. Qtractor is a more general
purpose sequencer,
I would say. However, built-in synth would allow you to do some things which
Qtractor
currently can't, like render all song to a file.
Also, I do not know of any LV2 synth that is a good drum machine. Someone
here said that the
GUI is disfunctional. But this is not true. You can by a single click assign
a different volume to a
drum machine note and in fact this drum machine is very nice.
If there were many high quality working LV2 synths, Wired would, perhaps, be
a matter of taste.
But there is no such thing today - the number of LV2 synths is small and
those that are there barely
work.
Only true for Qtractor, because older LV2-GUI are strongly bonded to GTK
wich makes it complicated for a QT-app to implement. This problem is
about to cease. In the meantime: most LV2-synths come with DSSI-Versions
distributed parallel that work perfectly well in Qtractor.
Regarding Wired: sorry to say that, but Wired never was more than some
nice screenshots from the dev's computers and a long list of promises.
Its audio system was built on portaudio and it never worked. So even the
versions that I managed to get to start where more or less unusable.
LMMS comes with a very similar concept, delivers more features than
Wired promises. It looks nice, has an intelligent drag-drop-concept,
built-in synths (no drummachine though) and the best:it actually works.
MDA plugins, for instance, do not give any sound in Qtractor. LV2 zyn
also does not seem to work
within any sequencer but the lv2 rack.
So Wired is an integrated music environment where you can save projects and
reopen them without hassle.
I would say it is a great project. It's just a pity it is in such a
half-baked state.
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list
Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
_______________________________________________
Linux-audio-user mailing list
Linux-audio-user@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://lists.linuxaudio.org/listinfo/linux-audio-user
