Hello, The subject is a bit misleading. Maybe it should say "allow getting ..." rather than "get ..."? On Thu, Aug 08, 2013 at 06:16:13PM +0800, Tang Chen wrote: .... > A node could have several memory devices. And the device who holds node > data should be hot-removed in the last place. But in NUMA level, we don't > know which memory_block (/sys/devices/system/node/nodeX/memoryXXX) belongs > to which memory device. We only have node. So we can only do node hotplug. > > But in virtualization, developers are now developing memory hotplug in qemu, > which support a single memory device hotplug. So a whole node hotplug will > not satisfy virtualization users. > > So at last, we concluded that we'd better do memory hotplug and local node > things (local node node data, pagetable, vmemmap, ...) in two steps. > Please refer to https://lkml.org/lkml/2013/6/19/73 I suppose the above three paragraphs are trying to say * A hotpluggable NUMA node may be composed of multiple memory devices which individually are hot-pluggable. * pg_data_t and page tables the serving a NUMA node may be located in the same node they're serving; however, if the node is composed of multiple hotpluggable memory devices, the device containing them should be the last one to be removed. * For physical memory hotplug, whole NUMA node hotunplugging is fine; however, in virtualizied environments, finer grained hotunplugging is desirable; unfortunately, there currently is no way to which specific memory device pg_data_t and page tables are allocated inside making it impossible to order unpluggings of memory devices of a NUMA node. To avoid the ordering problem while allowing removal of subset fo a NUMA node, it has been decided that pg_data_t and page tables should be allocated on a different non-hotpluggable NUMA node. Am I following it correctly? If so, can you please update the description? It's quite confusing. Also, the decision seems rather poorly made. It should be trivial to allocate memory for pg_data_t and page tables in one end of the NUMA node and just record the boundary to distinguish between the area which can be removed any time and the other which can only be removed as a unit as the last step. Thanks. -- tejun -- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-acpi" in the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
