On 09/07/20 20:22, Peter Xu wrote: >>> So I think Peter's patch is fine, but (possibly on top as a third patch) >>> __must_check should be added to MSR getters and setters. Also one >>> possibility is to return -EINVAL for invalid MSRs. > Yeah I can add another patch for that. Also if to repost, I tend to also > introduce KVM_MSR_RET_[OK|ERROR] too, which seems to be cleaner when we had > KVM_MSR_RET_INVALID. You can use either that or 0/1/-EINVAL. I would be fine with that to keep the patch small. Paolo