To justfy cross posting by Shyam Bandyopadhyay to many lists;
As I wrote:
shyam bandyopadhyay wrote:
draft-shyam-real-ip-framework
is a reinvention of geography based addressing not acceptable
by ISPs in the real world.
among many participants of all the lists, I, only on IETF list,
am the only person to pay respect to him by, spending some time,
reading his draft seriously enough to find a known defect.
Though he may be disappointed, it is better if defects, if any,
are found as early as possible.
So, he did the right thing.
Masataka Ohta
PS
Attacking someone's draft without reading it is a personal attack.
PPS
I found RINA, seemingly, have the same defect. I'll discuss it in
a separate mail.
