Hi Dan, Thank you for your review. On Wed, Jan 9, 2019, at 9:30 AM, Dan Romascanu wrote: > Reviewer: Dan Romascanu > Review result: Has Issues > > The document extends the Sieve Email Filtering Language [RFC5228] by providing > a number of action commands, some of which can generate additional messages of > behalf of the user. It is a clear document, its target being developers and > users of the protocol. I liked the fact that the authors included a > 'Compatibility with Other Actions' section that describes the interoperability > with existing deployed versions of the protocol, as well as the inclusion of a > temporary section about Implementation Status. I am missing however some > information about possible impact of the new action commands on deployment and > operations on servers already in operation. I assume that scalability and > compatibility between older and newer versions (including or not the new > defined commands) were assessed, but this is not documented. As :fcc is controlled by Sieve extension mechanism, Sieve scripts need to be updated before :fcc can be used. This means that either users need to manually update scripts and/or implementations that would use :fcc automatically need to be updated. So older (nonextended) implementations are not affected by this extension. Does this help or did I miss the point you are trying to convey? Thank you, Alexey > Some confirmation, > warnings (if any) and useful information that operators should know at > deployment would be useful. I suggest that you consider adding such a paragraph > or short section. >
