Hi Khaled,
At 12:46 PM 19-12-2017, Khaled Omar wrote:
I noticed that the IETF participants gives only negative comments
regarding the submitted IDs, that is good in some cases if it is
true, but to ignore the positive side and the added values on every
draft is something that should be changed, I always aim to find a
true technical discussion on the mailing list to add something new
or to correct something wrong with confidence.
Several years ago, I rewrote a draft and sent it to the authors as I
estimated that it would be less effort compared to the effort I put
in to follow up on the review of the draft. Is it worth reviewing a
draft if the amount of effort it requires is much more than the
effort the author put it to write the draft?
I suggest comparing (published) RFCs on the subject you are
interested in with the drafts you have submitted to assess the
technical and editorial level which is being sought.
Regards,
S. Moonesamy