Re: Last Call: <draft-ietf-sunset4-ipv6-ietf-01.txt> (IETF: End Work on IPv4) to Proposed Standard

["Paul Hoffman" <paul.hoffman@xxxxxxxx>]

This document is not ready for standardization because many statements 
in the document contradict each other. There are prohibitions that in 
one sentence have exceptions, but in another sentence do not have the 
same exceptions. The statements in the Abstract are much more 
restrictive than the statements in the body of the draft. There was 
nearly no discussion of the draft in the WG (a total of three commenters 
in WG Last Call, and no discussion before WG Last Call; the draft was 
discussed at no IETF or interim meetings).

Because of the significant number of contradictions in the draft, it is 
impossible to say whether there is consensus. The draft should be 
rewritten to be internally consistent before the IETF is asked whether 
there is consensus for the proposed limitations.

--Paul Hoffman